Zaffiro's Pizza The Original

Some of the best tavern style in the Midwest.

Great sauce, great crust, great environment!

Orderdd a half Cheese, half pepperoni, light full garlic, hair more sauce and well done. Didnt come out well done, but everything else was very solid. Great Wisconsin cheese, great cracker thin crust and cheese baked over the edge. No flop on the crust, very cracker thin crunch. Was really good...

Crust is paper thin, need to eat a lot of it to fill up. Overall good tasting sauce, but nothing to it that made it any different from any other thin crust pizza. Also ate it for takeout, so may have lost a bit of its freshness

8th Annual Pizza Review Results Group Average of 21 Attendees: Took 1st Place Out of 8 Total Stops -My #1 Favorite as well!

Sauce and cheese were wonderful. The crust was cracker thin and was not my type.

Cracker then crust with just the right amount of sauce, cheese, and toppings. Every single bite was delicious.

Just a classic bar pizza. Nothing special, but has a unique flavor. The crust is cracker thin, which I do enjoy. The sauce and cheese are pretty good. The authentic Italian atmosphere is something to appreciate. 7.6 that’s the review

Another very good pizza. Very nice and flavorful, you couldn’t really ask for a whole lot more in a tavern-style pie. Toppings were good, decent crisp, sauce was pretty spot on. That being said, nothing really stood out to me as being superb. Atmosphere was really cool and old-school. Overall, would definitely recommend this spot.

Most overrated pizza in Milwaukee. The meatballs were very good though.

Paper thin crust with a nice crisp and undercarriage. Great flavor with tangy sauce. Old school 50s pizza.

Good slice. Great slice.Cracker thin crust but not overdone.

Fantastic crisp crust. Flavor was perfect. Great balance of sauce and cheese. Place was packed on a Monday night..so delicious!

Excellent!

Pretty Yummy if you ask me

No flop thin and great!!!!!!!

Pepperoni and pepperoncini! Great Milwaukee pizza