aaron.tabackman11/26/22, 7:24 p.m.
This may be the best pizza I’ve ever had. New Yorker in New Haven to try the “best pizza in the U.S. The crust was the star of this show. It was just so perfect. Right in that in between point of crispy and doughy which is what good pizza should be. I had the 1/2 plain and 1/2 claim with mozzarella on the whole pie. I like Zuppardi’s approach. They don’t overdo it with the sauce and cheese. They take almost a minimalist approach to it. And on the clam side, the clams are freshly shucked so you taste that freshness in every bite. I’ve never seen lemon wedges served on the side of a pizza but when in Rome (or New Haven) do as the Romans do. Lemon juice topping it was. When I used to live in New Haven, I are Pepi’s and Sally’s and I must say that Zuppardi’s does hold its own if not surpass those legendary New Haven institutions. It’s the Big Leagues up here and Zuppardi’s hit a home run.
aidan.o'rourke11/22/22, 9:56 p.m.
Fantastic pizza gone before we could take the one bite picture
luigi.cusano11/19/22, 11:58 p.m.
Always delicious and as good as I remembered. Been many years since I have Zuppardi’s.
john.mucciola11/5/22, 10:45 p.m.
Very good a little floppy towards the middle of the pie but the sauce and the rest of the crust more than make up for it would definitely recommend
bkpizza16010/28/22, 10:56 a.m.
So Zuppardi’s is a few minutes away from Wooster but it deserves to be mentioned along with Pepe’s, Sally’s, Bar and Modern!! Incredible pie, I didn’t think I would have a better sausage slice then Modern but Zuppardi’s managed to deliver. Service was good, vibe of the restaurant was cool. Just another New Haven gem!! My favorite behind Sally’s my girlfriend felt it edged Sally’s out. Either way def try it. Great pizzeria with another cool story.
ant-raff10/27/22, 9:46 p.m.
Very thin n crispy with a good crunch in every bite. Not much grease at all even with pepperoni on it. Good cheese n sauce but, couldn't had used alittle more sauce !!!
everettlogan10/14/22, 1:35 a.m.
This is really excellent pizza (or apizza). The crust is about as close to perfect as I’ve had. Cheese was great. The weak link was the sauce. If the sauce were more flavorful, it would be somewhere in the 9’s. But, definitely worth a stop.
adam.durham9/27/22, 5:45 p.m.
Has the lightest crisp to go with a great flavor. Has buttery taste behind the sauce and cheese.
d-rock8/20/22, 4:20 p.m.
On the final stop in New Heaven, we tried Zuppardi’s. Probably the best crust out of anywhere in New Haven. Very good slice to end the trip. New Haven is truly the pizza capital in my opinion
subdiver7/30/22, 9:17 p.m.
Their cheese pizza is good at 7.9 but I wish the sauce had more flavor. But wow, their Shrimp Casino is awesome at 8.3! The white sauce is amazing! 8.1 average, go for the white sauce!
joe.jazz7/13/22, 2:25 p.m.
Good pie.. right up there with the other GOATS of New Have without the crazy wait.
kenneth.ochs6/26/22, 5:27 p.m.
Excellent quality, great pepperoni, great dough- high quality pie
pizzaaficionado6/26/22, 5:25 p.m.
Wow! Previously tried the location at THC. This, is legit. Blows that out of the water by almost a whole point! No flop. Great ingredients! This is up there some of the best!
kristen.greenblatt5/29/22, 5:25 p.m.
I love not getting my hands too dirty- mission accomplished! This had such a great, crispy and “clean” crust. I would come back immediately:)
steviegnj5/27/22, 6:07 p.m.
Had a frozen sausage and plain from Goldbelly and now stopped in for the real deal. Agree with Dave that the sausage pie is better. Crust thickness was uneven, but I enjoyed the thinner pieces as the cheese caramelized at the edges.