This should be the first place to come up on google if you type in “mediocre pizza.” Was it the worst slice I’ve ever had? No, but it wasn’t good, either. The cheese had some decent flavor but the crust was some of the worst I’ve ever had; it was barely cooked at all. Overall this was a disappointing slice and I think Dave even scored it a bit too high.
Order now on Slice
Order 2 Bros Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
aaron.rose75/11/22, 8:18 p.m.
Very solid for a dollar slice, thicker than most dollar slices, tasteful amount of grease, fluffy crust
christopher.aquilino4/10/22, 3:23 a.m.
2 Bros. Still $1 despite inflation. It’s *bad* New York pizza. There are better dollar slices, even at other 2 Bros. They're consistent but not factory-like consistent. Lemme tell you what you’re getting: same day dough with little rise, *thick* crust all around that's screen cooked on the bottom, little flavor in the barely there sauce or mozzarella, and yet it's a junk food value at $1. I feel like $1 slice joints should skimp on the cheese, use *more* sauce, and use less dough to sell at this price point and have a better tasting slice. They must not do that for some reason I'm haven't thought of. Anyway, I'll run down the characteristics of this slice down quick: Tomato sauce is like a loose, lightly salted 8oz can of Del Monte, not much of it is on here. If oregano is in it it's wasn't detectable. So the cheese to sauce ratio and placement was lacking. Cheese you can tell is lower quality, low moisture possible whole fat/part skim blend of preshredded mozzarella. Cheese burns to the cornicione like Domino's/Pizza Hut/Chuck E. Cheese. But the real issue is the crust. It's *thick*, has a pretzel-ey texture, little rise to it, and it's screen cooked so the bottom can't get that good char and crisp. Anyway, NYC runs on $1 slices. It's a value. We all see the lines out the door. But it's not good pizza.
steven.pileggi4/3/22, 10:30 p.m.
Complete lack of sauce on the cheese slice, usually served cold and has was too much dough. Rough crowd and not a good 99cent slice
delicious_mike10/29/20, 2:32 a.m.
Not the worst dollar slice I’ve ever had, but certainly not the best either. Cheese has a strange aftertaste.
rg718/28/20, 3:47 p.m.
Top 5 doughiest slices ever consumed. I get it’s a dollar slice, but it’s not good.
stoked_matthews2/14/20, 7:33 p.m.
No NYC flop. Very good for the price 2 slices and a soda for 3 bucks. I think Daves score is a little low. First slice I had was too doughy and about a 6.1. Second slice was crispier and warmer and a 6.9. Thats is a 6.5 slice of pizza. This is NY pizza. A little above average good size good sauce and cheese.
rkenny459/20/19, 3:32 a.m.
Might be skewed a very hungry after yankees game, and not being from New York this was the closest to my airbnb. Turns out not to bad 2 slices and a can of soda $4, decent crust, no punch to the sauce however. Solid late night slice.