Alfie's Pizzeria & Restaurant

Great selection of pizza slices from NY thin slice to Detroit style. I tried the tradition NY cheese slice and that’s what I’m scoring. It was good, didn’t blow me away but I liked it. The size of the slice and price was very good too. The Detroit slice was also good. But also didn’t blow me away. If you are a local to Rocky Point Long Island you won’t be disappointed.

Nice crisp. Sauce needs a little more seasoning.

Let’s start with the attributes…the pizza was perfectly cooked with a spot on cheese to sauce ratio. And when I say zero flop…I mean zero flop - with a perfect crisp and undercarriage. However, the sauce fell down a bit or this would have been a monster score for a Neapolitan/football style slice. The sauce just didn’t awaken the taste buds, needed some basil or oregano pop to tie the whole thing together. That said, easily the best on the North Shore from Riverhead to Smithtown.

Excellent Detroit style

Solid NY slice. I always judge a place first on their Neapolitan. This one is solid, especially for Long Island and the area. Great crust, if I was to split hairs I’d say I’d like the sauce a little brighter. For the North Shore of Suffolk this is a 9.4

One huge margarita slice, they had a bunch of different styles on display but this one was the obvious choice based on looks. Great taste, no flop, sauce isn’t too tangy. The amount of mozzarella is perfect, not too cheesy. Great crunch to it. Great margarita slice. Definitely worth the drive!