Amelia's Brooklyn Pizza

While the flavor was good, the execution was pretty far off. On the reheat, the top of the cheese was cooked “well” and the undercarriage stayed limp and somewhat soggy. If this was more crispy throughout, I could see this possibly creep into the 6’s.

Pizza is dry. Could use more garlic butter

This post is to set the record straight with the new owners. Very nice people but they totally changed the style of pizza when they took over. I had a rating of 8.9, which would be the highest rating out there in the county, but just to not hurt my reputation I changed it to a 7.1. ( picture is of the old masterpiece that once was😢)

Quality cheese and sauce. Well done of course.

Very good!

Very greasy, doughy no crisp. Decent sauce

Neapolitan slice average with little flavor ...Brooklyn Square very good with more flavor good crisp and airy middle .. overall I will combine scores to a 7.2

Flop but a good flavor from the cheese and sauce. Not the best crust but it gets the job done.

Great sauce great dough perfect amount of cheese. Only pizza I ordered in South Florida. Must try!

Cheese to sauce ratio is off. Lot of grease, very floppy. First bite was good thought I was gonna be impressed. But ended up getting old and bland midway through second slice.

Not bad. Good ingredients. Crust is meh and pizzia is pretty greasy. Personally like it thinner as well. Wouldn't go out of my way. Square slice was actually better.

Awesome NY Style Pizza. Definitely worth the trip!!!!!

Lotta flop, little greasy, pretty good slice

Very good pizza. Great sauce, nice flop, and crisp.

Great NY style slice.

As Biggie Smalls would say “ I love it when you call me square pizza”. This Brooklyn square packs a punch of flavor. Sauce is sweet and tangy. Slice is layered with a thin coating of cheese covered in sauce and topped with more cheese. I was very surprised from the first bite. The Bronx Bombers would be proud.