Amico's New York Pizza

Little flop, good under carriage. Nice sauce.

Excellent undercarriage. Would be nicely crisp but for the abundance of sauce and the oily cheese resulting in a lot of flop. Still, good ingredients and fresh made dough, so a solid slice. Definitely better as an entire pie, though.

Good NY-style pie, dough and ingredients are always fresh. The sliced sausage is always a winner for me. Get a side order of the garlic knots when you go, trust me.

Very nice place and nice people. Pizza was very greasy, bland in flavor, and floppy. A bit more picky as a NYer I suppose but this was not comparable to a good NY slice unfortunately.

Very good.

Good NY style pizza in Nashville is hard to come by…this is a great family owned spot that does a great job. Maybe a little higher score due to scarcity but definitely worth stopping in for a few slices

The best around Brentwood - not quite NY/NJ pizza but very good

Fantastic pizza with solid meatball subs and pasta dishes

The pizza was very decent. I ordered a takeout but by the time I got home it was cold. Tried to reheat it, it helped a little bit. The sauce was very flavorful and the crust was very good. The rest seemed a little soggy. If I would’ve dined in and had it fresh I would’ve scored it a lot higher. This is definitely worth a Dave review. The atmosphere and the ambience is very surreal. Unfortunately it’s one of the suburbs south of Nashville that is so isolated that there’s no way it will ever get reviewed properly.

It’s not bad, but it’s definitely not great. There’s no crisp in the crust except for the handle crust, and the crust itself is bland. It’s also kind of greasy. That being said, everything else is at least decent. This had to be reheated in the oven because it was take-out. It would be better if it was fresh so I feel a bit harsh posting this review, but that’s just how I feel about it.

Listen pizza in Nashville is mediocre at best most of the time but they do it better than most!

We were pleasantly surprised. Looked a little messy but tasted great. Crust was thicker than I’d normally like coming from a Jersey guy. Great taste though!

good slice

Ask for well done and it’s .7 pts much better Frankie.

Good slice. A lot of flop.

Solid pie! Will definitely go back.

Great crust

Really good pizza!