Amore Pizzeria & Ristorante

Classic NYC slice! Good crisp, little tang in the sauce- but has a bit of flop. Definitely a must-try spot for anyone that enjoys a good slice. They have a good variety of specialty pizzas, but it’s hard to pass up a good cheese pizza! They also have black & white cookies that are phenomenal!

a little more pubic hair and this would of been a ten

Little New York flop but has a nice crisp, good sauce, cheese is good but wish there was a tad more, pepperonis taste fresh

Got it well done and the crust was perfect for me. Nice crisp, not too floppy and the grease wasn’t out of control. In NYC it would be a 7.6

Very solid pizza. Not a lot of flop. Meatballs were really good. Lasagna was also not bad. Cannoli’s are A1.

Been waiting to do this one. Only crust in Indiana that's not doughy. Beautiful char on the crust. Ok, here's the real story... When my mom was having trouble getting around we would stop by here after her doctor appointment. We'd come in for lunch with our NY Giants apparel on and the guy was always so helpful seating my mom. He'd then give us free bread sticks. We lost mom this year but I will always be appreciative of Amore. 7.8 for the pizza. 9.9 for the service.

Very average pizza. Not terrible but I wish zionsville had better pizza.

One of my Goto pizza places when I need to feed the family or bring a youth team in for a pizza party.

It’s pretty good Frankie!

The dough is a little tough, good pepperoni though. Really good spice to the meat. Quality cheese and solid sauce. The dough and crust really hurt this slice

The closest thing to a NY slice in Indy. Not much flop, a little bit of grease, great cheese/sauce ratio. Also, the pizza looks much better in life than in the photo.

A little grease. 10%-15% flop. One of the closest to NY Style pizza around Indianapolis.