Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

Sauce is excellent

Best in 🗽🍎

Very good pizza. Most of the flavor is from the sauce which is on the sweeter side. Crust is cooked well to bring out all the flavors. Cheese is the perfect amount.

Damned good.

Flavor good but floppy crust

Delicious, and I can sometimes eat a whole pie! It’s so good! On a “side” note they also have great fried calamari. I’ve eaten here at least 7 times and they’ve never served anything less than an amazing pizza!

Great experience. Little flop in the middle, but great slice overall.

Very flavorful, perfect texture. A little dry for crust but everything else was amazing

Was visiting New York on a Wednesday. Decided to stop by Angelo’s since it was close to the hotel. The place had a nice vibe. I grabbed the seat at the bar, ordered a nice Brooklyn logger, which came in a frosted mug. points there for the bartender. Since it was my first time there, I asked a bartender what should I get? He recommended the old-school round as that was the most popular dish. By the way, unless everything on their menu sounded delicious. The pizza came out looking gorgeous. It was solid. A real good pizza and not disappointed. Nice balance of flavors. Nothing overpowering. Is this a pizza that I want to immediately go back to when I’m back in New York? Not really. Still searching for that Wow slice.

Really good coal fire pizza. Great sauce and nice and crunchhyyyy

The mix of the dough, cheese, and pepperoni is heaven. It does have a bit of a flop. If the flop was gone, I’d throw it a 9.1

Holy cow thats a pizza had a little but of droop, probably caused by pie being too hot put into the box, but still great

Unreal. Excellent crust and undercarriage. Cheese and sauce were amazing. Bonus review - Angelo’s Chips are a 9.6 appetizer.

Best pie! Great pie! Wonderful pie! Sexy pie! Crust is nice and cheese is to die for! Maybe more sauce is needed? The dough is the game changer! Show me! BAM 9.3

so so good recommended sauce extraordinarily good.

89, 8990 this was a cumulative score containing six people. We did the large plain pie and everybody loved it. Can’t go wrong here, definitely recommend this place.

Excellent pie. Maybe a little too much crust and too lite on sauce. Overall a good pie.

Sauce game was a little weak, everything else was on point

Loved the sauce, probably best part of the pizza. No flop, crust was crunchy. Slices were small but that was probably because I got the 13in. Cheese was a bit parmesan-y

9.1 would order only cheese next time