Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

F me this was good

This was definitely a favorite. Super light, easy to eat and the sauce was extremely flavorful. Char on the under carriage was perfect and the quality of the ingredients were top shelf. If you’re near Central Park, you need to check this place out, like now!

Incredible

Under carriage to die for and super light on the stomach. Added a little parm red pepper olive oil salt and black pepper and it was fantastic.

Great pie, fresh ingredients, no flop and perfect crisp!

Good pizza

I don’t have a picture of the pizza so I’m just uploading this. But this is a horribly overrated pizza and Dave needs to review this place again because it sucked. And it sucked a lot it really had no flavor and was just an overall bad pizza probably wouldn’t eat it again.

Super crunchy! Fiancée loved it and she’s picky. Zero flop light sauce. Very good!

Lotta crust. Inconsistent cook. Not much cheese and not a ton of flavor to the cheese. Sauce was great. Crust was chewy, light, and airy. Toppings were great. Service was A+++. Good crowd pleaser type joint but not pizza-crawl worthy.

Good but overrated. Bland cheese, floppy, too much crust. Nice tangy sauce and good charred undercarriage taste but this is nowhere near a 9 and I would never take anyone visiting here who is looking for the best of NYC.

Excellent pizza.

Best pizza I have ever had, sauce, crust, seasonings all delicious.

Delicious. Crispy, flavorful, and great taste.

Good pie however no real crunch… We know the rules, old review hyped up scores!

COULD THIS BE #1 IN NYC? it is absolutely in the same league as Delucia’s, Rubirosa, Prince Street, and Grimaldi’s no flop, amazing crust, sauce is nice and bright and tangy

Crisp, light, great sauce!