Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

Best pie I’ve found in the area to date. Yes I’m here for 6 days and I’m checking out a new place everyday. Day 4 found this guy. I’m not a fan of a lot of cheese as I’ve stated on my 3 other posts but this place unlike the others at least uses good quality cheese. Taste is spot on. Good crisp. Two negative s. No oregano shakers and not well done as it states on the front door. ;). I was afraid to ask first r well done after see the door. I would eat again.

After 26 days in the hospital I finally get a good pie. Sorry for the horrible selfie video. Boy do I need a beard trim.

Decent pie. Would get again, but wouldn’t go out of my way. Sauce was a bit watery. Crust was fine. Overall if it’s convenient go for it, but nothing to write home about.

The crust was amazing! Both crunchy and soft at the same time! If you ever have opportunity, go!

Really tasty sauce and cheese. Inconsistent crust - some parts crispy and other parts doughy - and a little too much flop.

The pizza was chewy, but had excellent undercarriage and a nice Coal Fired Oven taste. The score would have been in the 9's if it had a little more crisp and texture was less chewy. Nice, tangy thick sauce with excellent taste. The sauce makes the pizza, and this place proves it, it has just the right amount of cheese. Great atmosphere in this place!

Very good very crispy. Sauce has plenty of flavor. Definitely will come back.

Thin and very crispy, sauce tastes good. Little flop but still a very good pizza

I like the thin crust but the cheese is tough and sauce is bland.

Great tang!

Long wait for takeout and wasn’t real hot when it came out? Traditional style pie, could be better (sauce and timing) Good crisp

Knock your balls off good. Sauce is spectacular

Expensive but you get what you pay for. Very good. Crispy crust. Tasty cheese and very good sauce

Underwhelming for the plain pizza. Some of the specialties and toppings looked good though.

My name is Sean. You all know the rules. One bit: it’s super moist.

Limited flop, nice crispy crust and char. Good solid savory sauce

I went for the first time and their oven actually shut off. The staff rushed to get the oven back up to temperature. We waited about an hour until the pizza came out, and it was worth the wait. The staff and general manager were incredible. They comped us this small cheese pizza. The ingredients were fresh, not much tang. Had a good no flop. It’s an 8.1 on an off day, can’t wait to try it when they are on their game. Again, I can’t stress enough how great the staff was at this location.

Its ight NJ pizza is better by a mile

Decent slice but nothing to write home about. Very nice crust. Little greasy, no flop, and needs some extra sauce.

Kind of disappointed with this one. No flop but a lot of grease, not a lot of taste with the cheese or sauce

Great pizza little pricey