Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza & Wings

I thought I remembered this being really good pizza years ago. Had both types of cheese (diff ones on meatball + margarita) but that’s the only difference. Thought it would easily be well into the 7s based on my recollection, but no. Only thing working for this pizza is the undercarriage

Wasn’t very good. . Sign on wall says “Well Done” .. it was not. Tasted like TV dinner pizza.

It was cold, hard to score properly

definitely a high quality Pizza worth driving for

It’s not pizza place pizza

Tried the complementary 12’ in pie (from joining the coal fired club online). Coal Fired gave a decent flavor on the crust. Crust could have used a bit of a chew though. First bite I tasted the mozzarella (whole milk) cheese, ironically best part of the pizza for me. Sauce was just okay. Bonus Review: ordered meatballs, didn’t blow me away 6.1

The crust was crispy as expected but also somewhat dry. The sweet sauce brought out some flavor. Try the garlic knots if you’re here, very good.

Had this a couple of weeks ago and forgot to log a score. It really hit the spot the night we had it. Good cheese and crisp on the meatball pie. We will be back trying other slices for sure.

My kind of pizza, good crisp, tangy sauce. Brittany our server was great and Jason makes a mean pie!

Said well done on the phone.. even says it on the box... only thing well done is me with this pizza

Good crisp and sauce / cheese combo. Little greasy

I thought the pizza tasted excellent. Some might say that 8.9 is too high but I’m not a tough critic when it comes to pizza. I like pizza. And this is one of the best one’s I got. The wings were excellent too.

Light, thin, crispy and just a slight flop. Sauce is fresh crushed plum tomatoes with a lot of tomato taste and just enough scattered throughout. Love the cheese! Anthony’s delivers on a well charred pie if that’s up your alley. Love it here!

Not enough sauce.

Not gonna lie.. hate well done, crunchy pizza. I’m looking for a pie with some flop. The establishment does stink but this pie is good. Football pizza for the rich. Saucy, cheesy and fresh. They lost points for not having ranch dressing (yes they even serve wings.. psh unreal) 6.8

“Tell em’ Joe B sent ya!”

A little NY flop. Slight charcoal taste. Sauce is a little tangy if you’re into that. Overall it’s some pretty good pizza. I’ll give it a 7.4 Frankie.

Solid brick oven pie.. great crust

Strong recommendation. Get the traditional well done.