Anthony's Food Shop

Solid crisp. Zesty sauce. Good crust. Minor flop. Best slice of pizza in York. New York style

Great sauce quality and char. The 6.7 overall review is garbage. This place is a solid 8!

Super gummy crust. No flavor. Maybe I have COVID...

Great crust, A LOT of cheese but not enough sauce. Great pizza though, the market is a cool place too with a ton of different food options you should check out if you’re ever in the area.

Great pizza. Best place in York hands down.

About as average as you can get. Could be crispier would have helped the score. Decent sauce. Good cheese.

One bite everyone knows the rules! Decent sauce to cheese ratio. Definitely some re heating going on or something because it’s fairly greasy. The grease doesn’t stop it from scoring a solid 6.9 though

One bite, everybody knows the rules. Solid football pizza. Very thin, reminds me of Joes NY Pizza in Portsmouth. Good slice. 7.5 - That’s a review.

Superb slice. Well sauced, good cheese, and the flop does not detract from the experience. Frank’s Red Hot is available near by. A hidden gem.

Crust is doughy, lots of grease and a basic sauce.

Nothing jumps off the page with it but it’s good pizza.

Quality slice, great flavor, great crust, not much grease. Definitely recommend.