Order now on Slice
Order Baby Tommy's Taste of New York
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About Baby Tommy's Taste of New York
227 Yelp Reviews
elchivogringo12/9/21, 5:50 p.m.
Decided I was going to review before I came in today. Very nice and crispy undercarriage. Quality cheeses. More than an average football pizza. Must get the thin crust. The Sicilian is too greasy and not crispy enough for my liking. I guess that’s personal preference though. I’ve had mixed experience with consistency in the past. I hope this is the new norm.
tony.szabo10/18/21, 3:30 p.m.
Nice combo. Extremely fresh and filling. One slice is plenty at this location in the heart of Marietta! Wound recommend the brownies - might be homemade !
chris.abbott8/22/19, 8:27 p.m.
Solid crust. No flop. A little disappointed. I figured with a name like ‘taste of ny’, it would be better. It’s not bad. Solid football pizza. But not award winning either.
grant.hinton3/13/19, 5:00 p.m.
So the tomato garlic bacon was definitely one of the better slices of pizza I’ve ever had. Crispy, lots of flavor, but the toppings weren’t in the cheese they were just kind of on top of the pizza. GREASY, like a fuckin oil slick this pizza. But! Still a great slice. If I were rating it alone......7.8 but I also got the spinach artichoke etc. and that was a floppy soggy mess like a sock in a pool. 4.2
wrongomer2/15/19, 10:42 p.m.
Cheese is more floppy than a hooker in Vegas. But, dough is good and sauce is good. Stuffed pizza brushed with garlic butter, and adds a nice touch.
jeffepizza1/23/19, 6:18 p.m.
Good slice for non-NY/NJ pizza. BUT...the place is pretty scuzzy. Furniture is crap to sit on.
stefan.melton12/27/18, 9:49 p.m.
This is horrible pizza. It’s so soggy you have to eat it with a fork. Soggy as a wet paper towel. Mush in your mouth.
djbarrio9/5/18, 12:31 a.m.
Perfect crust, great taste and great cheese to sauce ratio. Could use just a little more cheese and sauce, but otherwise this is amazing pizza!