Top Restaurants

Bartone's Apizza

Bartone's Apizza

143 Main Street, Derby, Connecticut

Pizza Review

0 likes

mike.fernino on One Bite Pizza App

mike.fernino

7/22/25 3:24 AM

There is good and bad here. First the good. The pizzas look fantastic and they have a great char. Crunchy crust. The crust is definitely the star. Now, for the not so good. I really was disappointed with the sauce. It’s spicy not sweet or tangy. I would say bold with a bit of a kick. I’m not a big fan of spicy, so it didn’t impress me. I also ordered a white pizza and I ordered a meatball. The meatballs were on the doughy side. I wish I can give them a better score but I’m being honest that it’s definitely not for anyone who does not like spicy.

Pizza Review

gdrush11/10/25, 4:20 p.m.

8.4

Really good sauce to cheese ratio, sauce is amazing, crisp/crust is perfect. Right up there with Roseland in my humble opinion!

Pizza Review

svatzini9/15/25, 11:00 p.m.

9.0

This place is way under the radar for being sandwiched in-between Roseland and Tipsy Tomato in Derby and not far from New Haven. Have been many times. The owner makes every pie that comes out of that oven and they care deeply about the community. The pizza is straight-up excellent. The Red Raider (their tomato pie) is about as get as it gets and some of the specialty pies, like the Stuffed Shrimp (pictured) and even the scary-sounding Cheeseburger pizza are really excellent. The stuffed breads are great, too, as are the salads. Fantastic spot!

Pizza Review

scarlettbuttons9/12/25, 12:41 a.m.

9.1

This bacon pizza hits the spot 🍕🔥 Crispy crust, gooey cheese, and smoky bacon in every bite. Definitely a winner! I will be back!!

Pizza Review

norge.mastrangelo9/11/25, 11:12 p.m.

10

When moving to Connecticut, from New York, I was worried I’d never have great pizza again. That was until I stumbled on to Bartone’s!!! The best pizza I’ve had in years and wait until you try their stuffed breads! The owners are some of the nicest people you will meet and I promise you this is a can’t miss! Absolutely incredible pizza!

Pizza Review

richard.bartone9/11/25, 9:40 p.m.

10

Perfect pizza best in the valley

Pizza Review

gary.pettinella7/22/25, 6:08 p.m.

9.0

Went with a classic, Large pepperoni 18” pie great flavor, crispy crust Travels well Definitely a must try Became my weekly spot for takeout

Pizza Review

cassandra.raye7/15/25, 10:41 p.m.

8.5

Best New Haven Style around!