Order now on Slice
Order Bay34th St Pizzeria
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
About Bay34th St Pizzeria
409 Yelp Reviews
onenonlyjigsaw12/8/21, 10:30 a.m.
Honestly not bad. Taste was a little generic though. Also tried to Buffalo Chicken Pizza everyone raved about… 6.0 on that, not great. Regular cheese was solid and not a disappointment, 6.9.
jeremyhannah6/25/21, 11:54 p.m.
Local spot that we’ve had delivered a few times. Decided to eat it in person to rate it. Just a floppy, average pizza. Even letting it sit for five minutes we couldn’t keep the cheese on it. It was a floppy mess. Ordering well done may help the score. Just an average neighborhood pizza. I’d pick it over one of the chains, but that’s about it. She said 7.1, and so did I.
mitch.parga6/23/21, 5:25 p.m.
Pizza had great undercarriage, no flop. The crust was perfectly crispy with a great texture. The taste was absolutely delicious probably one of the best crusts I have had. The Buffalo chicken was absolutely amazing. I will definitely be back.
steven.schweigert5/27/21, 5:12 p.m.
No droop, great crust, great sauce... the oven is old and seasoned. Great people and family owned/operated.
richard.breuninger5/10/21, 12:37 a.m.
Crust is fantastic, good flavor to sauce, not super greasy. Also tried the Florentine slice. Very good!
ray.blanco4/27/21, 6:40 p.m.
Love the crust, love the undercarriage. Unique taste. I never pass this place and not grab a slice. Staff is great... Mom and Pop place!
20 views•0 likes
matthew.ben-shabat9/25/20, 9:24 p.m.
Nice under carriage, cheese is great, and just the right amount of sauce.
graham.makel3/16/20, 8:39 p.m.
There’s a Pizza Hut next door if you pass by this place for Pizza Hut you are an idiot go get a good slice here
jon.horskey10/21/19, 6:28 a.m.
Pizza is great so is the interior. Polite staff and clean. The real gem here is the buffalo pizza. By far the best I’ve ever had. 9.2 on the buffalo pizza.
cooper.eddy7/29/19, 1:21 a.m.
Classic Dallas flop which I have now coined. It flopped literally as much as a slice could. Tasted like a thinner version of Papa John’s. It’s not bad at all. Just nothing great.
ericcartmenez10/28/18, 10:38 p.m.
Good football pizza. Crust is good, sauce is a little weak, greasy but I don’t mind. Solid pizza, beats a chain any day. That’s a review.
matthew.rutherford10/16/18, 5:07 p.m.
Great pizza! Buffalo ranch is the best... great people and service.