Benny Tudino's Pizzeria

Gimmicky pizza. It’s about the size, not the taste. Good value tho

So heavy. So mediocre

Great Pizza! Best in Hoboken 👍🏻

This is the biggest slice of pizza I’ve ever seen. It needed two plates. That alone makes going here a fun experience. Sauce is excellent, cheese could be a little more flavorful, and the crust is meh. The pepperoni slice is a whole different game though. I’d recommend that over the plain.

The cheese, sauce and dough are a perfect blend. I have eaten at so many pizza spots, and this is the best hands down!

Amazing. Agree with the rating. I murdered two slice. One cheese and one pep. 🔥🔥🔥

Way too much flop, too much cheese but slice got better as you went on. Solid crust.

They have good days they have bad days for the size and the price automatic 7 on a good day 7.5

Gotta say I was hoping for more! Crust was raw half way through. Sauce was good and size of the slice was great. I’m hoping it was an off night but tonight the review is....

Great pizza

Huge slices are usually just a gimmick to sell less than stellar pizza. And while this pie isn’t great, it’s not nearly as bad as you might think. This is the NJ equivalent to the NYC dollar slice as far as quality goes, not price. The dough is super soft, like a dollar slice, with thick, doughy crust. The cheese is pretty standard, a generic blend that isn’t terrible. However, the sauce is surprisingly tangy and very solid, the one thing saving this pie from dipping below a 7. This joint is a staple for the after hours crowds piling in after the bars close because on a drunk pizza scale, this is a 9. But if you’re looking for a sober slice in Hoboken, this is decent; but you could definitely do better and a lot worse.

BIG.

Better than it should be considering a slice is the size of a baby. Minimal flop, tasty cheese and sauce but a little too doughy and needs way more crisp

This isn’t the large slice, but still a decent pie. If the crust was crispier we’d be talking 7s.

Great large slice and love the rest of the food.