Benny's Pizza - Lynchburg

Seth and Lorenzo take on Benny’s: on par with Dave’s score. Great for Virginia, but as native New Englander’s it’s a solid score for this area. But no where near new england style pies. 6.7 THATS A REVIEW!

I’m going high on this review because usually the bigger the pizza, the lower the score per Dave’s rating. However, this was a GREAT slice with an amazing undercarriage, perfect amount of sauce and cheese, and a great value at $5 per slice. The size was was almost as much volume of like an 8” - 9” pie but worth the price 100%. If you are drunk or starving, this pizza is probably like 9.3 but I believe a 7.6 is a really great score and I would recommend. I like this Bennys better than both Roanoke and Blacksburg too. The location is not super hard to find and it’s plenty of street parking so at most you may have to walk like .2 miles to get to. Worth a trip if you’re in the area!

Huge slice. But the cheese end was better than the crust end.

This is what pizza should be! Just moved to Lynchburg area and have been looking for a good pizza spot! This is it!

Paper thin crust for a 14 inch slice. Sauce is used sparingly, but there's just enough.

Great flavor, awesome crisp for huge slices.

The pizza tasted old and just reheated. I like a little crisp but not so much I cut my mouth. I would be interested in tasting a fresh pie but this was disappointing. I know I ate it but I paid $5 for it and wasn’t going to waste though I only needed 1 bite to score this.

Pretty solid cheese slice. Lots of flop which I like.

Crust is bland, sauce is chunky at the top and tastes like somethings missing in the sauce

Crust crispy and delicious

Good crust. Solid crunch/flaky. Huge slice is cool, but not practical. Flavor isn’t bad. Definitely better than a lot of pizza in the area

Family had it. We all voted and took the average. One of us had too high of a score. Decent football pizza. I'd eat it again but it's not the best or the best in town. Give it a shot.

This pizza could have my kids.

Solid Pizza

Solid pizza, needs a better sauce and a little more crisp. Prez would call it drunk pizza

It’s really good large pizza! Let’s get StoolePresidente to come here!