Big Bill's New York Pizza

First time at Big Bill’s. Ordered it well done and it had absolutely zero flop. Very crispy and cooked to perfection. My favorite for best pizza place in CO and could compete well in NJ/NY.

Great under carriage. Good crunch. No flop. Solid pizza

Good taste and toppings just a bit light on sauce

I am from the Metro region and for Colorado this is the closest thing to NY pizza your going to find here. Perfecto

A little floppy but still a good undercarriage. Solid crisp. Sauce was great. Good amount of cheese. A little too greasy. Overall, this is as good of a New York slice as you’re gonna get in Colorado.

Big Bills NY Pizza ⭐️ 6.9 12 inch $13.75 (PPI = $1.145) Sauce lacked flavor. Cheese was good, didn’t slide. Undercarriage was firm but not crunchy, had more of a tear to it. Crust was good, had a crunch. Overall - Great neighborhood value, worth the visit if you’re in the area. Cool spot to visit and the people were also amazing. Friendly and gave great service. 10 - Best I’ve had. 9 - I will tell everyone 8 - I will drive out of my way 7 - I will be a regular 6 - I will say it’s good if asked 5 - I will go if a group wants to 4 - I will suggest something else 3 - I will not go 2 - I will actively warn people 1 - I will consider calling the health dept.

Reviews look great. Was excited for the pizza. Just to be let down for just OK pizza. The crust was the best part and even that was still mediocre at best. Sidenote, clearly Bill was never in the Boy Scouts because there’s a huge difference between knots and balls. Don’t call doughballs, garlic knots.

My favorite New York style

No flop, great under carriage, not too crisp, excellent sauce.

Large Pepperoni. Not bad. Taste was good. Really floppy and really greasy as you can tell by stained box. 6.9 is a pretty good rating for this pizza since there’s really nothing better in this area for pizza.

Asked for crispy, great under carriage, always a solid NY slice.

One bite, everybody knows the rules. Decent undercarriage, quite a bit of flop, decent ratio of cheese to sauce. Decent pizza.

Classic NY flop not the best big bills I’ve ever had but the beer is hitting and atmosphere is a 9.2. Also CU is the greatest 1-5 team of all time fuck you mel tucker

This is currently my Top Rated Pizza spot in Colorado. Very Good!

Slightly greasy, good flavor and cheese to sauce ratio.

Get the green Chile base.

Great pizza. Picture doesn’t do it justice. Just a well balanced pie

Great vibe in this place. Pie is good. Garlic flavor is very nice. Crust is thin and just right. Get you a slice.

I’m a nostalgic sucker for the Big Bill’s cheese (don’t judge me because my father likes Hawaiian). I really love this pizza, it can sometimes be a little underdone, but nonetheless a great slice with great flavor. Also, unrelated to the score, but the garlic knots are amazing

Do yourself a favor and come get this pizza. No flop, great flavor, a little runny. This pizza is great overall.

Have been coming to this place with my family for years now. Thin, light, crispy crust with the perfect ratio of cheese-to-sauce. Even saw the owner Bill walking around and talking with customers which is special.

Very good solid slice

Under cooked, otherwise excellent. Sauce and cheese were fantastic. A little doughy due to under cooked . Next time I'll order well done.