Big Boy's Pizza

First with the original - undercarriage was solid. Barely any flop. The sauce was very bland however and there was not much cheese. Also, a lack of seasoning The grandma slice was very good and gets an 8.5. Amazing slice. Great crunch, combo of sauce and cheese on this slice was definitely a step above the plain slice in my opinion. The man taking my order made me feel like I was in a real pizza shop. Being called “boss” has to boost the morale a little for sure. I wish I could average these two because the grandma was awesome, but have to stick to the OG plain slice

Big Boy's Pizza offers a solid pie, with some room for improvement. The undercarriage is a standout, perfectly cooked with no flop, and the crust is good overall. One area for enhancement is the cheese and sauce blend. While blended well, the pizza could benefit from a bit more sauce to elevate the flavors. The cheese, while plentiful, was a bit bland. However, a sprinkle of crushed red pepper provided the needed kick to liven up the taste. Overall, a decent choice, especially if you're a fan of a well-cooked crust and don't mind adding a touch of your own seasoning.

Vodka slice, cheesy and good

A solid slice. Order a pie. Could use more sauce on this slice. I've had a better slice before here, but it's still pretty good.

Great selection of available pies/slices. I opted for the Grandma and was not disappointed. Flavorful sauce but no garlic overkill. Crunchy yet chewy crust. Gotta come back for another variety.

Had the Grandma Pie and it was very good. The sauce was sweet and plentiful with a soft chewy undercarriage and supported by a nice crispy edge. However, the 2 middle slices (absent of the crispy edge) did not hold up as well to the wetness of the sauce and really flopped.....but overall the expected flavor of a grandma pie was achieved and made this a very enjoyable 7.8

Good hold and undercarriage. Cannot say there is much distinctness in its flavor between the sauce and cheese. Sauce needed a little kick.

Crust was lacking and the sauce a little too sweet for my style. Would definitely go back for their signature grandma pie to give it a shot.

Ordered grandma pizza (added sausage). Good crunch on crust, great flavor with tomato sauce. Haven’t tried the traditional pie, but grandma had great texture and flavor.

Great covering of good cheese with a nice low key tasty sauce evenly distributed throughout. not much flop but the dough / crust could use more flavor.

Dave this is for you!! If you want crust like a bar pie but in a full size slice this is your place. Any specialty slice from the case is just as thin and crispy. My new fav spot for sure!

Definitely the best grandma I’ve ever had in jersey. Great service and great food overall.

New owners was the old romeos pizza is excellent