Big Joe's Pizzeria

Got a giant slice, sicilian and a soda, $11.25 out the door which isnt horrible. The regular slice is monsterous...basically 2 slices in 1. Here to rate the sicilian though. Gonna keep it short on this one. The sauce....solid. good taste. Good ratio. The cheese...decent. the dough and crust is overcooked to hell and dry as can be. None of that fluffy chewyness that i love. Cut the roof of my mouth on the crust itself. One of the few times where i like the regular much better than the sicilian.

One Bite Everybody Knows the Rules. Huge slice. Major flop in the middle of the slice which is weird. Almost like the middle wasn’t cooked through. Oily. Sauce was tasty and crust was good. Had the Sicilian and that was real good. Might go back for that but not the regular huge slice.

I never had a pizza with this much topography. Some parts were really thin and floppy- others were thick and doughy- and still other parts had pools of oil- but none of it was very flavorful. It’s just a generic slice- I give it a 5.2 - the grandma slice was surprisingly decent despite its looks. It was crispy, rich with bright tomatoes with a basil zing. I rate it a 6.7

Nothing exciting, very plain pizza, didn’t want more, major flop

Delicious and giant slice! Sauce was good. Crust was good. Little greasy but a little grease is expected. I was pleasantly surprised and full! 🍕

Everybody knows the rules.... greasy,floppy and not that best flavor. The slice is giant so it goes a long way price wise, but that’s all it’s got going for it.

No sauce, just cheese and bread

Definitely good football pizza good crisp and a decent amount of tang. Little greasy.

Great pizza place. Good slices

Very thin slice with massive flop at the bottom of it. I would consider it drunk pizza. Huge slices also. 6.4, that’s a review!

Decent football pizza. Needs some more flavor and more sauce. Other then that not a terrible slice

What a great slice!! A bit large but sauce and cheese are great crispy crust. Good slice

Classic Long Island pizza but jumbo sized. Good ingredients, thin slightly sweet crust, I’ve had before and will have again. Solid pizza