Branchinelli's Pizza & Restaurant

Awesome Pizza

Very good pizza. Came out quick. Sauce was very good. Crust had a smoky flavor. Perfect ratio of cheese.

Ight

Got a pie this time to give it another try. The regular pizza is fine, the selections beyond remain thin. Nothing special about the slice. Has a nice cook but the overall flavor leaves room for improvement

Very good pie, big slices!! Good sauce on the sweet side, mild crunch , but a fluffy crust , not too much flop, would recommend if you are in the area

About well cooked as a thick slice could be. Great undercarriage, but fell down a little on the crispness. However, the star was the ingredients, quality ingredients = quality flavor. Really enjoyable slice!

Sicilian Pizza is the best. Colosseo is a 9.4. Branches is just a little bit under them. Still, some of the best pizza in NY!! Dave needs to come here and Colosseo

Excellent white 8.4 Sicilian bland sauce dough raw 5.2

Branchinelli's makes the best pizza in Suffolk County. The sauce is delicious on the regular slice. The Everything Slice is excellent and their red sauce for dipping is top tier!

Little greasy but grea

Terrific Undercarriage! Crisp. Cheese was very good as well.

Like it’s sister location, a solid reg slice. One of my go to spots in the area.

Nice place good service but sloppy slices most of the cheese falls off and is stuck to the plate. Needed a knife and fork. Slice taste below Avg at best

This was me after eating brachenelllis. Take that as you will

Place was packed like a stuffed bra. The only problem was when the bra came off the goods weren’t there. Middle of the road pie.

Two good slices. My new favorite spot in the area. Normal slice: slight flop, good crunch tho. Cheese was above average but there was a ton of it so that boosts it. Sauce had a nice unique taste to it. I give it a 7.8 Sicilian: pretty doughy but still had a crunch. Cheese was good and spices different than the normal slice. Sauce was tasty as well. 7.6

This is what I call “football pizza”. Thick crust for NY style. Tasty sauce laid on a bit heavy though. I like cheese so didn’t mind it was also laid on heavy. I’d stop in again if I’m in the area.

Grandma style - greasy crispy and pepperoni perfectly charred on the edges. Bonus point for the excellent 70s original decor.

Branchinelli’s Pizza Rating - 8.1/10 Great regular and Sicilian.