Brooklyn Pizza Masters

Very good, but not an 8.5. Crisp/flop is out of this world, but the crust is thicker and doesn’t have a ton of flavor. Cheese and sauce very good, but slices were super greasy. Overall very good slice, but not in NY’s S or A tier.

Really good NY pizza

Larger than average slice. Sauce is very lacking. Nice airy slice but I just feels like there’s something missing. Unrelated to this score, the Sicilian slices are amazing. I would give those a 9 score. The regular slice doesn’t have the same magic

Really solid pizza with good ingredients, the pizza was well put together and had a good crisp. The staff were also very friendly and the place had a laid back atmosphere.

Very floppy but very good

Never gonna complain about it, just nothing special about it.

Really good slice here. This is their magherita. It’s a heavy slice but the dough held up nicely. Had really nice flavor and fresh cheese. Definitely the winner of the 2 slices I had. Also had a Sicilian square (that’s the crust in the pic). Crunchy square with upside down style. Like the previous slice the flavor was solid. I went 7.7 on the Sicilian square. Really good variety of slices here. I must’ve missed the plain in the window cause I didn’t see it, but I guess it was there based on previous reviews.

Good Sauce

Love this place. The crust is crunchy and the sauce is tangy. Better than Ignazio’s

Great sauce and ingredients. Ordered incorrectly but the quality is outstanding.

We were doing a pizza tour. On the first bite, this was definitely better than the last place. Light. Definitely a good pizza.

Great consistency amazing crunch

One block from where my son lives, tried a Margherita slice and vodka grandma slice (wifey had a white pizza slice … ricotta spinach artichoke) Basing my score on reheated slices. They use good quality ingredients but not worthy of 8s, slices were very good and I’d be very happy to have this pizza restaurant near me. But would not drive an hour for it, hence 7.9 Next time I visit my son, perhaps I’ll order a fresh whole cheese pizza and give it a accurate score.