The Square is a solid 8.1 in the “Square” realm, I would just get the square. The regular is very disappointing- major flop, thin but no crunch whatsoever, very greasy..Regular is a 6.4
Order now on Slice
Order Brooklyn Square Pizza
Hungry? Order right now on Slice
artie.mase5/26/23, 1:16 a.m.
Offensive lineman. Light on its feet. Good tasting sauce. Crust was perfect.
dicicco.cosentino7/7/22, 4:32 p.m.
The vodka Square was by far the best Of this bunch…it’s easily a 7.7- the upside down Sicilian 6.4 - I really didn’t care for the sauce at all. It’s too sweet and lacks flavor. The bake was nice though. The regular slice was a very basic 6.2. It’s decent but nothing to write home about.
jason.forman1/20/22, 9:40 p.m.
Regular has an interesting tang to the sauce but nice crispy slice. The Brooklyn square is in the name and clearly lives up the hype.
jay.marine11/16/21, 7:10 p.m.
For the first time, I’m not scoring the regular… when the place is called “Brooklyn Square Pizza” I feel they should get a pass. I liked it. Would definitely come back. Solid 7.8….
sgt.pizza6/1/21, 5:48 p.m.
Regular: i didn't find it to be terrible. It obviously wasn't the best ive ever had. It was thin with a slight crispy to the bottom. I would consider it a soft slice, sauce is on the sweet side. 7.2 Square: crust is as close to spumoni as you could get. The sauce is not quite the same though. I feel this sauce is sweeter. All and all a real good slice. 8.2
brian.roberts55/26/21, 6:43 p.m.
Sauce was really weird, grandma slice was awful like 3.1, regular just was just not good
bowmansmash5/19/21, 8:39 p.m.
As close to L&B Spumoni Gardens as it gets without the trip and traffic to Brooklyn.
buske2/12/21, 11:03 p.m.
Really good pizza.Love the sesame seeds and the pasta I would like a little sauce on it but I still love it ❤️❤️ Maddy
jason.cataldi12/18/20, 8:10 p.m.
This is the reason you come here. Very “old world Brooklyn“ slice. Nice quality ingredients. Not too heavy.
conwayeric7/28/20, 8:34 p.m.
Don’t do the regular have to go with the square. Sauce is above average and crust is unreal.
cole_p2/10/20, 1:40 a.m.
A good slice, thin crispy crust with no flop. Not much flavor with the sauce, good cheese. Overall a good local slice. If your gonna go you have to get the square, it’s very good.
anthony.desena1/22/20, 8:24 p.m.
I really wanted to like this pie but i was not very impressed. It was so soft it reminded me of a italian deli tomato pie. Not a ton of flavor. It also could have used a bit more cheese.
robert.detrano8/6/19, 7:15 p.m.
Was here for lunch had the regular slice and a vodka slice both had a good sauce to cheese ratio and were a little crispy no flip at all. Regular I give a 9 and Vodka I give a 10. Dave and Frankie have to go here.
anthonyg8/3/19, 10:09 p.m.
The Brooklyn slice was incredible, probably scores in the high 8’s on its own. Regular slice was solid, no flop and above average.
brian.tinney8/3/19, 10:08 p.m.
The traditional brooklyn style square is truly incredible. I would go a 8.4 on the traditional. Speciality slice is solid. A bit of flop ect. Overall great place. Atmosphere is a 10. Yes a 10.
z.worthington7/28/19, 7:51 p.m.
I set out to review their copycat of L and B Spumoni Gardens. I’ve never had L and B, but this was pretty darn special. Crispy bottom, pillow like dough, cheese was good though i think they went a little light on it. The sauce is where this square will win you over. I really enjoyed it.
angelo.luparello7/22/19, 9:10 p.m.
Rated by mistake at 5 that was a mistake this is a 8 plus the upside down which should be named the Sicilian or the Angelo
iv.menache7/21/19, 7:36 p.m.
Good slice would like a little more cheese and maybe a little more sauce. Sauce has a special taste to it.