Brother's Pizzeria

Damn, this is good Sicilian pie!

Great cocktail party, Richard. By the way, where'd your wife get her

I grew up around the corner of this precious place circa 1985-1993. This place defines the Staten Island pie- not your thin bar pie or overly doughy Sunday football nj plaza slice. Instead, it hits heavy with cheese- the best ingredient , with not compromising on the sauce or elevated crunchy dough. Surprisingly, no flop with the heavy cheese. John Franco would approve (as a bonus John Franco gave me the finger when I was 9 at a Mets game and yelled at him for blowing a save against the marlins).

Closest pizza to NY Style which is My favorite. I drive to have a slice or pick up a pie. This and Moon River are the best I’ve had in Jacksonville.

Had some better pies from them. It’s a classic old school New York slice. Big slices. If you a little bitch that like little slices because you are afraid your belly might roll over the front of your pants. Then this isn’t for you.

Was recommended the Sicilian slice. It was just average.

Great undercarriage and sauce but not a fan of the cheese - it’s a bit extra and greasy

Absolutely delicious

A little cheesy, some flop, decent sauce

Score for the Sicilian. Nice crunch good sauce. Regular I’d say a 7.1. Very cheesy a bit too oily for me. Had a bite of the vodka square which was great might come back for that,

Great pizza. Would be rated higher if not for the chunks in the sauce.

Amazing straight up Sicilian slice. Airy light crust thick sweet sauce and cheese that pulls for days amazing flavor, corner slice as usual, perfect ratio, little bit messy but so damn good

Really a shame for a pizzeria with such a good reputation, but I just paid $34 for an under cooked pizza. Raw dough, uncool.

Good sauce and cheese flavor.

Best Squares on Staten Island!

Best Square on the island, crunchy bottom light and airry in the middle. Great sauce and just the right amount of cheese. Always get the corner as well. Dave should come back for this slice.

Sicilian slice

Always great pizza tastes like a meal in your mouth. Great sauce,cheese and crust. No flop, little greasy, solid pie

No flop. Lots and lots of cheese. Thick dough. Good taste. Good pizza for football and drinking. Very very greasy. Overall good pizza and solid taste. Very filling.