Butch's Grillacatessen & Eatzeria

Ordered delivery & showed up fairly cold…Not their fault. Had my oven pre heated at 425 before the pie arrived just in case. Had it at a 7.1 on the first slice. After throwing the rest of the pie on my pizza pan in the oven for 3-5 minutes, solid 7.6. Haven’t tried Goodfellas yet. But I hear that’s the cream of the crop in Bloomington….TBD

First I need to lower my expectation, I’m in a college town. Sauce and cheese were not that bad. It’s the dough that was a failure for me. Change the dough (no sugar)! 00 Flour, Sea Salt, Yeast and Water. Cook a bit longer, need a better undercarriage.

Buy one get one slices on Tuesday, gotta try them all!

Best slice in town. Rockit fanboys won’t agree , but that’s okay. New York ranking would be in the 7s/10, Btown wise the full 9/10.

Greasy, but very good cheese and sauce

Best pizza in Bloomington 10/10 on a local scale. Nice and cheesey

Rookie score

God father is the best pizza there

Quality football slice, wish the crust was a little more crunchy but overall solid

Being from the east coast it’s hard to find good pizza in Indiana but this place does it right and does it GOOD

Best N.Y. style pizza in the Midwest.

Closest thing to east coast za in the Midwest, very solid for Indiana