Carlo’s Pizza

Ordered the personal pizza. Great job keeping the crust thin. Pizza was cooked perfect, nice crunch and the cheese had the slightly orange I like.

Portnoy effect = 3 month wait. Looks awesome & good crisp with zero flop - wanted to love it but even accounting for a frozen slice there are better options...

Frozen Carlo’s Pizza from the Portnoy effect. I scored before I tried the crust. The crust is Crispy and Tastes like a local NY Style spot in my town. I still feel like this pizza didn’t separate itself much from the grocery store frozen options. Still, the Crust is really good. I add my own pepperoni which also makes this pizza better.

I had this pizza sent from Atlanta to Boston so this review is not based on right out of there oven in there shop..with that being said this is a very good pizza very crisp crust nice cheese the sauce it not packing a ton of flavor but it is just fine I'm sure if I got this hot out of there oven it would be in the mid 8's...but frozen out of my oven 7.9

Ordered this 15 minutes after Dave posted his review, took 1 month to arrive. Excellent pizza, glad that I have 4 more in my freezer ready to go at anytime. If I ever make it to Georgia I’d love to try in person. 7.8

Ordered frozen pizzas and 18 business days later still hadn’t been shipped so you get a picture of my rug. I also despise a place that has a family member give their own food a 10!

Yo! Best pizza I ever had! Hand tossed right in front of you. And they were making meatballs from scratch while I was watching the pie be made. They let me sample! Melts in your mouth. Incredible. Getting the meatball sub next time I'm back! Stop by this family owned pizza shop. 4 brothers. They'll take good care of you! This is real pizza in a very classic shop! My new favorite spot!

Best pizza I’ve ever had! Barstools has to do a review of this place! Family owned and great ingredients.