Carlo’s Pizza

Portnoy effect = 3 month wait. Looks awesome & good crisp with zero flop - wanted to love it but even accounting for a frozen slice there are better options...

Frozen Carlo’s Pizza from the Portnoy effect. I scored before I tried the crust. The crust is Crispy and Tastes like a local NY Style spot in my town. I still feel like this pizza didn’t separate itself much from the grocery store frozen options. Still, the Crust is really good. I add my own pepperoni which also makes this pizza better.

I had this pizza sent from Atlanta to Boston so this review is not based on right out of there oven in there shop..with that being said this is a very good pizza very crisp crust nice cheese the sauce it not packing a ton of flavor but it is just fine I'm sure if I got this hot out of there oven it would be in the mid 8's...but frozen out of my oven 7.9

Ordered this 15 minutes after Dave posted his review, took 1 month to arrive. Excellent pizza, glad that I have 4 more in my freezer ready to go at anytime. If I ever make it to Georgia I’d love to try in person. 7.8

Ordered frozen pizzas and 18 business days later still hadn’t been shipped so you get a picture of my rug. I also despise a place that has a family member give their own food a 10!

Yo! Best pizza I ever had! Hand tossed right in front of you. And they were making meatballs from scratch while I was watching the pie be made. They let me sample! Melts in your mouth. Incredible. Getting the meatball sub next time I'm back! Stop by this family owned pizza shop. 4 brothers. They'll take good care of you! This is real pizza in a very classic shop! My new favorite spot!

Best pizza I’ve ever had! Barstools has to do a review of this place! Family owned and great ingredients.

One bite, you know the rules. Best slice in Atlanta. Very much reminds me of Jersey style pies. Really fresh ingredients, great meatballs, and fazool is killer too. Dont miss out on this place.