Carlo’s Pizza of Port Washington

Sicilian slice was excellent, nice crisp, great sauce, and crust was spot on. Also had the buffalo slice which was absolutely enjoyable, not much flop, not to much chicken, excellent.

Really good but occasionally on the crispier side for my taste

Absolutely great pizza. Love the cheese and Sicilian. Workers are very nice. It’s crispy, cheesey and it melts in your mouth. Would recommend

Floppy and overly cheesy. Sauce flavor doesn't come through enough. It's good but not great

Classic Old School NY Pizza. I like my crust a little thicker, but that’s a personal preference. This pizza is very GOOD!

Fantastic no other words necessary 👌🏻

No rookie scores here but the guy who uploaded a tin of cheese and rated it a 3.4 must own another pizza shop in town. This is the best slice Place pizza I’ve had on Long Island. There’s a reason this place has been open 41 years: top tier ingredients, top tier staff, top tier tradition. Pizza like this is why the US is the greatest country in the world.

Best slice there is.

Best slice in New York

Amazing pizza! Looked beautiful right from the start. Best pizza in Port Washington, NY.

Always my go too. I always lean towards a classic napolean and Carlos does it best here in Port. Great by the pie but even better by the slice! Very good Grandma as well.

Regular: thin and crispy, real good cheese to sauce ratio. Sauce tastes great and not much grease. Real good slice 8.2 Grandma: I cant tell you how many places get this slice wrong. This is not one of those places. Real good cook on the dough and a delicious carmelized bottom, and delicious sauce that is not overpowered by garlic. This is seriously a top 5 grandma slice 8.9 Chicken and peppers: structurally it holds very well. A lot of weight to this slice and no flop. Dough is good chicken is a little dry. Peppers are a bit overcooked in my personal opinion. I would prefer them to have a little crunch but some people may prefer it the way it is. All and all it's good. 7.9

Amazing pizza just ask for the pie to be lightly oiled. Good light crisp amazing sauce and cheese.

This Pizza is a I-formation run up the gut of the defense. Great solid fresh tasting sauce with great cheese. The middle of the pie could use a little crisp undercarriage but otherwise great football pizza.

Good slice, a bit greasy though but over all one of the better options in town

Best pizza in Port Washington

Definitely a solid slice and good football pizza. Crisp crust and tangy sauce but a little on the greasy side.

Crispy cheese is good no flavor of the sauce

16-1