Carmella's Pizzeria

Best pizza on Aquidneck Island by far. People sleep on Carmella’s.

5.5 & 6.5 = 6.0 (rookie score) and… that’s a review

Get a Thin crust cheese pizza it’s the best one on the island. I go there regularly, it’s a no bs score

The ingredients are fresh, crisp and delicious. A high pizza spot on my list of spots

Great place. I always try and visit when I’m in Newport.

Crust is amazing. Sauce is good.

A little heavy and slightly greasy, but tastes pretty good. Football pizzaish

Pretty good pie! Way better than Nicolas of Newport

The Carm

Pizza was good not great. It was very greasy but not to the point were it was disgusting. The cheese tasted very good and the sauce was ok. The crust wasn’t too hard but not too doughy. Overall pretty good.

Good flop and perfect amount of cheese to sauce ratio.

If u like good pizza this is the place for u. Good crust. Cheese and sauce mix well together. Overall good pizza. It did not have the flop that I was looking for though. If u don’t like waiting then don’t go. it took a long time to make.

Gold medal slice was okay. They need to cut their slices better which is annoying. Steak and cheese was a solid 7.9, but that's not the gold medal.

Today this pizza had decent Newport flop, but high quality ingredients make this a solid choice when on the island. They'll also deliver 3 floors up with a smile.

6.1 the best you can get in Rhode Island

Considered by many locals this is the best football pizza on Aquidnick Island. Flavorful sauce, plenty of cheese and a great crust. Try the veggie if you’re into that sort of thing.