Carmine's Pizza

That’s me heating the slice I ordered up in my oven, because it was ice cold. Ordered it 2 minutes before. $5.75 a slice. What a disgrace.

Not sure if it was just because I was feeling the generational vibes on the Cape or what, but I scored this a whopping 8.2. It was flat out great. Truly love at first bite. Generous on the cheese and pepperoni, and approved the crust as well. If I ever make my way back to Chatham I will be a repeat customer. Yours truly - Luigi Za aka ZaPizzaExpert

The sliced tomatoes were excellent. I also really loved the Pesto specialty pizza (not pictured) Pesto and ricotta base was remarkable. If you're planning a pizza night in Cathom, this is the spot.

Ordered well done for pick up. Came out with a slight crisp. Little floppy. Sauce has some flair but dough is a little bland and overly airy in crust without the crunch. Solid pie with sauce as the highlight.

This place used to be much better. We ordered 2 pies and both were doughy and floppy. No crisp on the crust at all. Sauce and cheese were OK.

A bit greasy, pepperonis cooked well

CARMINE’S IN CHATHAM, MA 7.5 CHEDDAR JACK REVIEW #87

*OFFICIAL REVIWE* Mid pizza

Best pizza in Chatham, hit this spot every summer. 🍕

Good undercarriage with a little bit of a flop. The crust is a bit floury but it goes hand in hand with the sauce that is fantastic and fresh. Almost tastes like a resort pizza. Would give this a try if you find yourself in Chatum looking for pizza not worth a pilgrimage down from other towns but definitely a must stop if you’re near Chatum. 7.1 lock it in 🔒

Pizza by the slice! Good fresh pizza! Crispy crust

Tastes like if Costco were an Italian

Pretty good crust, pretty good sauce. Cheese leaves more to be desired. Overall a solid slice

Crust has a nice crisp, solid undercarriage, sauce is on the sweeter side, but pleasant, and the cheese is pretty standard. Overall, solid slice, especially by the beach.

Great football pizza. Sauce tasted fresh and has just the right amount of tang. Sauce to cheese ratio was spot on. Underbelly has major flop could use more crisp.

Hits the spot when you’re hungry

nice and crispy crust - perfectly done. solid and quality pizza

Surprisingly really good! A shocking crisp that I wasn’t expecting and no flop. A yummy sweet sauce and nice cheese and a great crust!