Carnegie Pizza

It was fine.

Really good

…looks like a typical football pizza but surprisingly taste really good. Crust nice and well done and crispy … tastey perfect amount salt sauce .. very good pizza in time square area where most pizza spot taste like dollar slice … well made pizza and will go back!

This is one of my go to’s on my commute home. Really legit slice. Good sauce, savory with a hint of oregano.

Nice slice. Didn’t like the fact it was reheated. The sauce and cheese were good, not great.

Nice thin crust, sweet taste and right out the oven

Yummy bite on perfect dough sweet tomatoes and fresh mozzarella, good slice

Trying to get the rating up because it’s delicious

Like the basil. Good fresh sauce and cheese. Crust nice and soft.

The definition of New York Pizza. Crunchy thin crust and a great browned cheese coating. Overall way above average pizza would definitely come back

perfect crunch. super hot. little oily but amazing regular ny style slice

This was a solid slice of pizza. I like how when they reheat the slices they do it up so it’s nice and cooked with a good crisp and nice and thin. Margherita cheese was a bit gummy but overall pretty solid nice ratio to crust cheese and sauce

The buffalo chicken and pepperoni were hot and tastier then ever. A thin soft slice with a good amount of cheese. The Sicilian slice was cheesy and very salty with a good amount of oil on it.

Pretty solid. Great taste, fast and not that busy.

Nothing special, just a solid slice of pie

Really nice crust with a crunch. It needs more spice though.

The spicy pepperoni is the star!