Caruso's Pizzeria

I don’t understand some of the other reviews. This is a very good slice. Clearly above average LI football slice. A lot of game here. The flavor was good, maybe a touch more of oregano or basil in the sauce was needed. But overall, solid! Thin and tasty with a great undercarriage.

Legit slice. Light, thin, won’t weigh you down.

Great crisp slice! Great sauce with fresh basil. I would return!

Perfectly baked crust

Solid football slice. Used to go here years ago when this lil old Italian guy was always making the pizza. Haven’t seen him in years, stopped going. Came here to score it and it was better then usual honestly. Cheese, sauce, ratio all good. Lil crunch. It’s a nice!

We just stumbled upon this place, pretty good!

Extra floppy, tastes great, but needs mas crunch!!!... stellar knots tho!

One bite everyone knows the rules..... Pizza comes out of the oven at a nice temperature. It has almost no flop and looks like an ironing board when you lift it off the plate. Visually this pizza is a work of art. It stops there. Like the hottest chick in highschool looks is all it has. Absolutely no personality. You might as well of put fake mozz and sauce on this monster. The sauce had zero tang of sweetness and the mozz might as well of been shaved wood chips. I've gotten more flavor from being dared to eat packing peanuts at my first warehouse job. The bottom crust while crispy has ZERO texture. I can't give this pizza a bad score because the taste wasn't bad it just wasn't there. If the chef put half as much attention into flavor as he did presentation you'd have a decent slice.

Very similar to Rocco’s but missing some of the flavor

Caruso’s makes a solid slice. The sauce has a sweet aftertaste, the cheese is quality, and the crust is crisp on the outside and soft inside