Cascarelli's Pizza

Loaded with toppings and extra extra cheese. Didn’t cut well

Quality pie. Good sauce and nice crisp crust. Lots of cheese. Definitely one of the better pies you’ll get south of Detroit.

Pizza review: 6.5 the pizza itself wasnt outstanding but it was alright. the sauce was bland and there was a bit much for the ratio of sauce to bread. this is also a pizza you eat with a fork and knife Overall Review: 7.0 The sides were good we had the pretzel and cheese stick thing the atmosphere was also good

This pizza was a suprise! First off definitely the best square cut and crumbled sausage pizza I have had (both not my bag). Got the traditional Pep, Sausage, Basil. This pie was packed with flavor! Cheese was cooked golden brown and crust was crunchy and chewy it blew my fucking mind! Loved the fact they put premium Pepperoni under the cheese! If staying in the Coldwater area would suggest making the 20 minute hike to grab a slice. Place looked cool inside. Bonus Review- 7.4 for Annie's Bread its like Bosco sticks cut up into bit size pizza rolls covered in garlic butter. Tastes good but feels like I need to take a shower and brush my teeth with all the garlic and grease

Pretty good sauce, decent crust and cheese. Coulda been cooked better but definitely good for the area.

Really damn good pizza.

Great pizza, and great service

Good pizza over all, a little bit soggy on the dough!