Caserta Pizzeria

Best pizza in RI hands down!

6.3 and that's being generous. If you look at the picture the back half of the pizza had no crust. Barely any sauce or cheese and the crust was generic. They told me 20 minutes, I showed up 5 early, and waited for the remaining 5. They called my name, I opened the box and the pizza was already lukewarm. Positives were it was crispy and no flop. Disappointed as all hell.

Yum! Good spot! Honestly thought would be better! Dave’s review was accurate

Well I can say this. If the score was based on presentation it would be in the eight’s. That being said I had to give them a 6.2. That could be a better score but we got caught in traffic and it was sitting for an additional 15 minutes. But that’s my score!

Great Pie, tangy sauce with perfect ratio. The cheese is clearly high quality. I recommend the pepperoni as well, old school.

Not enough sauce

Small mushroom and olive.

Nice crunch, and good flavor.

Small cheese pizza. No flop. Robust sauce, cooked well done. Thicker pizza

I needed for it to be hot and fresh right out of oven. Mine wasn’t and score reflects that

Fantastic pie. Light and airy crust, but kind of a hybrid between regular thickness and deep dish. Sauce and cheese both had fresh flavors. The more I ate of it the more I liked it. It’s a bit unique, so if you only like thinner slices, this might not be your place.

Not really living up to the hype. El Pres what were you thinking with that score?

Best pizza in RI. Loaded with toppings and the dough is super crunchy, totally disagree with the 7.4 from el presidente

Overall, a little too bready; I’m more a fan of the thin/crisp, but you can taste the authenticity of this place in the sauce

Skip the wimpy Skippy unless you really love spinach. The regular pie has zero flop, very good, tomato is very fresh and sweet. Compares to Prince pizza but better

Very unique pizza. I liked the crust and sauce a lot. The ladies working there were great. I’ll be back and I want to try the large it looked more Sicilian.