Chatty's Pizzeria

Good but not great pizza here. I really enjoyed the crust, but wish it was a little tighter as there was quite a bit of flop - still good taste. The multiple cheese blend was solid and the sauce had a pretty distinctive tang that I thought was ok, but could see others loving. We drove 45 minutes to try the pie… probably wouldn’t make that drive again, but would definitely be in the regular rotation if I lived in the arena.

Looking at all the other reviews these have all been rookies but they've been close but not for the right reasons this place is a little charming place with great people the pizza itself was spectacular the crunch no flop if I was to get really picky the sauce would need a little bit more tang and maybe a little less cheese but spectacular people and pizza we know that it's all about the pizza not the people or the place this is a place that's not ready for what's going to happen to it good luck everybody but this is an 8.1 maybe an 8.2 for real good luck El president

Great tasting pizza and that CRISP was perfect. Meatball appetizer was also lights out

Sweet meat was great. Awesome undercarriage. Great tang to the sauce. Awesome staff.

Bueno

First time here and we were really impressed. Multiple crust options, including cauliflower. We got the sweet meat pizza on the grandma’s style crust and the Cacio de Pepe on the NYC style thin crust (well done for both). Great flavor and crisp on both. We will absolutely be back

Good flavor. Best mushrooms on a pizza I’ve had in a while. Bay flop. Undercarriage could have been stronger. Solid slice.

Greasy as sleeping with your friends mother. Solid

Best NY style on Cleveland’s west side

Great pizza best in the area.

Great crunchy taste and good undercarriage, but other than that it’s just a above average slice of pie nothing too crazy

Very good crust

Pizza is great, call ahead and it will be worth the wait. You can thank me later. Great staff

Had the Sausage and Rapini, tomato basil and a BYO that were all amazing!

Clam pizza was awesome. So far my favorite pizza joint around. Great location and wall murals too.

Unreal. Grandmas crust is 🔥🔥🔥🔥 Good sauce and quality ingredients.

A really great spot to have dinner near the lake. Pizza is made from scratch and tastes amazing! Portnoy would rate this place in the high 7’s!

Great service. Good crunch. Pepperoni was great. Cheesy. Will go back and try different one.