Classic Slice

I think Dave let emotions get in the way of better judgement. It’s good pizza. Little flop, sauce is tangy. Crust is a little chewy, but great flavor.

First off, what a sexy pie. The 4.7 Dave gave this place without even trying their pizza is criminal, and this would’ve been right up his alley. Awesome char and crisp on the crust, and the undercarriage is spectacular. Very nice taste with good sauce and cheese. I will say, it was a little on the greasy side and it’s a little pricey, but worth it to me for MKE. Some of the best in the state, definitely in the conversation with Wells Bros for that title.

This pizza has a lot of good qualities. The sauce, the crust, and the cheese are all very good. It is a great style, not too thick but also has crunch and is lighter. Alright 8.1 that’s the review.

ver nice👍👍

I’ve eaten A LOT of pizza. Their pep slices are an easy 8.4 and one of the best slices you can get in all of Wisconsin. - Josh Meyer

Great crisp. Better than expected

Stopped here after a full day of travel basketball. Both these slices cost 17.50. Little pricey but this slice checked a lot of boxes. Good undercarriage, no flop, very crispy, good sauce and cheese. A lot to like about this place even with the high slice costs

I didn’t realize you only got a minute to review. So pizza review time..a little greasy up top but the crunch on the crust is delicious. Sauce is spot on and overall it’s a great slice.

Super Friendly Staff. Huge Slice, and garlic knots were excellent. Will be back. Portnoy, you did them a disservice by rating them a 4.4 when you didn’t even try their pizza. They were closed for a staff meeting. Sorry your ego was crushed because they didn’t know who you were.

Oh my gosh it was so bad. Mostly a burnt rock hard crust. The sauce was too much and was so chunky (I don’t like that, some might). Even the workers were just unfriendly. Skip this place tbh

Good under carriage, slight sweetness to the red sauce, cheese was good. I enjoyed it.

Really a good slice. Thin crust, tangy sauce. Really good stuff!

Serious flop. NY style Pizza. Good crust although extra doughy.. sauce is light, toppings are fresh.

Excellent pizza with extra sauce, crust is like a Baggett it's pretty awesome

Delicious Detroit style pizza with bacon. Has a Chicago style butter crust that’s crunchy and crispy on the bottom and chewy in the middle. Super cheesy with delicious crispy smoked bacon. I like a saucy pizza, I really wish this would have had more sauce. Sauce was rich and flavorful, and seasoned well. If Detroit style isn’t your thing, they offer large Wisconsin style pies. All Ingredients are fresh and all sausage and meatballs are made in house. So so good!

Excellent sauce, flavorful sausage. Not much grease. Great looking undercarriage. Decent pizza. Also tried their Detroit style pizza (not pictured). Very filling, but not as good as the standard pie. 6.7 on the Detroit style.

Good pizza. Little to no flop. Good large slice. A bit of grease but not overbearing. Overall, it’s good quality pizza.

Good quality pizza. Little greasy, decent crunch. Wouldn’t drive too long for it, but a good local joint.