Colony Grill

12/4/24 - Arlington, VA Colony Grill ⁃ Slice Style: Bar Pizza • Appearance/Presentation: 3.6/5 • Notes: greasy • Taste: 4/5 • Notes: • Sauce/Cheese/Topping ratio: 3.8/5 • Notes: • Dough: 3.7/5 • Notes: Crispy • Crust: 3.9/5 • Notes: Thin ⁃ Total Score (1/10.): 19/25 = 7.6/10 ⁃ Price (worth it?): $10.50 (yes) • Additional Notes: Lil Greasy, but could eat it all day. Hot Oil/Pepperoni toppings

Good but nothing by special. Probably wouldn’t go out of my way to get again

The waitress had a cross necklace

As good as the original in CT. Double sausage and hot oil. Yum

Love a good bar pie. Good crust and sauce.

not bad not great, tasted like glorified frozen pizza. super oily. i did like the thinness and crispness of it but it's very average

Thin and crispy. A little greasy but just as good as the original location

Got black olives and cherry peppers. Paper thin and great flavor. Insane bar pie. Great spot too.

Best pizza I’ve ever had. The hot oil is a great touch. The crust had a good crunch.

Great crisp but flavor is a little lacking. Maybe ask for extra sauce and well done.

Very thin, super crispy, needs more sauce. Excellent pizza!

Cracker style crust with a great crisp, doesn’t sit too heavy after you eat it. Good flavor

I must’ve gotten a bad batch or something because I really did not enjoy this pizza. It’s too crackery with a ton of grease. Not to mention how I spent my next 24 hours on the toilet. Really disappointed with this pie considering the hype it had.

If you like thin then you will like this. I got mine well done and the char was magnificent. Sadly I got it delivered and so it wasn’t that hot when it got to me, but that being said it’s still very good. Probably more like an 8.5 hot

Unique. Crispy. Cool spot.

Hot oil really really good. Super crushable with a nice caramelized crust. Normally go plain cheese but had to try what they’re famous for. Highly recommend

Amazing, great taste! Thin and solid under 🔥🔥

Best bar pie around.