Colony Pizza & Catering

Nice, thin wood fired crust, pretty standard quality toppings. Sauce is nothing special. Could use just a bit more flavor but undeniably satisfying. Good amount of pep coverage but they could’ve used more char

Always fresh, cooked to perfection. Great sauce and under carriage. Def top spot in Erie

In terms of Erie pizza places, this is easily a 10. One of the best in town but I am a bit hesitant to score any pizza too high so I’m keeping this one in the eights. It’s basically the same recipe as Steel City but there is a slight advantage here. This slice may have been sitting out for a while but it was still good, obviously you’re going to have a better experience with a fresh pie but they do right by their slices. Folks who value their crisp should be happy with this. Definitely recommended.

Very good pizza. Service a 10. One of my favorite pizzas.

It’s almost impossible to get a slice of pizza in Erie anymore, but Colony Pizza isn’t your average Erie Pizzeria. This pizza has a Jersey/NYC vibe. The best slice in Erie. Hands down.

Hey Davey Boy. Eric C From Erie Pennsylvania Again! I am giving a legit score on this amazing pizza near Presque Isle Beaches. I have genuinely reached out to you on Facebook with my post and reached out to Barstool. This homemade thin crust from heaven is bomb.com. The delicious taste of the quality cheese. The mouth-watering homemade sauce is to die for. The owners are hard-working and personable, and I am begging you to come to Erie Pennsylvania Pronto. Bring your high noon. Bring your best appetite to be welcomed with open arms to a beautiful city and to a pizza that can not be beat here. When you are done devouring this pittsburgh style pizza, it is a must you try his Ma's Almost Famous Cookies. They are so soft and moist, and his elderly mother goes into the pizza shop weekly to provide these fantastic cookies. I bet you eat this pizza quickly, and you order one for the road back to NYC or back to Boston to share with your closest entourage. Contact me. Set this visit up. Makes this family's life a dream come true. Eric B and his wife Mm All I am looking to gain is a friend and proof that valuable people still exist. 8.9 freaking fantastic pizza that is a review. Thank you for highly considering this visit, and if I am wrong or right, I will donate to one of your charities or a business in need. Enough talking, let's have some action...

This is a legit pizza excellent crust great sauce light on the cheese but overall excellent

Fantastic Pizza. I'm a big guy who likes the good things! Best Pizza I have found in Erie County so far! There are a handful of Greats in Erie, but Eric B sits on top!