Colosseo

Their pepperoni bacon and hot honey is great, I just picked up a whole pie to bring back to Long Island

Margarita slice was very good!

Thick and doughy solid slice

Our first Sullivan County pizza to try before going to the Woodstock Museum at Bethel Woods! We’re in Monticello, and OMG the pizza was absolutely delicious!!! Michael’s rating: 9.5 Chicken Caesar Salad slice: 9.5

Pizza was just okay, it was super doughy and I prefer my slices to be crispy. Sauce and cheese was good though.

Mediocre at best. Not enough sauce. Cheese and bread were ok. I usually add points for grandma (because it usually the star), not in this case. Less than mediocre. Bring your par-baked pizza from the city.

Regular cheese slice was cheesy deliciousness indeed. I also had a pizza mia slice which was dynamite. Fresh tomatoes, spinach, garlic and grated parmigiana. It’s an 8.9 specialty slice.

No flop, thick slice, a lot of cheese and crispy crust. This place really brought it with their pizza! The sauce was sweet but mild and the undercarriage was not burnt at all and held it altogether. This was really a solid pizza pie.

The Grandmas Pizza is absolutely the BEST pizza I have ever had. I literally downloaded the One Bite app just so I could tell the world.

Crust is doughy. Body of the slice is light.

Football pizza. Thicker crust, good crisp, good cheese and sauce action

Crust is different crispy outside but unusually soft underneath lots of cheese and a sweet sauce not my kind of slice but still a good slice

Good tasting slice could’ve had crispier crust and a little less cheese overall recommended by the king

Much less saucy than Beyoncé on the Lemonade album. Slightly more spicy than Jose Reyes’ walkup song. Not bad overall