Colosseo Pizza

I can only rate based on the slice I got. I stopped in for a slice in my way to the ferry. The place looked good and the kitchen was busy. I got a simple cheese slice. It was super floppy, greedy and doughy. Left my stomach feeling upset. Was not impressed at all.

crispy, cheesy

Just what is expect from a high quality New York pizza. Great flavor and sauce.

It is a pretty good pizza but wayyy to much flop and is way to cheesy. But it does have nice fluffy crust.

Amazing overall, would recommend to anyone in the area

Little flop but a very good slice the buffalo slice though is a solid 9

Best pizza on Long Island

Could have been cooked a touch it more, but overall a great slice.. sophisticated football pizza. They use a great sauce, not overpowering with flavor but it’s different. Perfect amount of cheese busy place for a reason

alrighty frankie youll love this Sicilian slice ! davie not so much but one of the best on island!

Have yet to top their Grandma Pie.. it’s elite and my favorite slice. Comparable to Branchinelli’s (same owner)

Pizza is excellent, nice undercarriage and crust. The flavor from the cheese and sauce is very good. A little greasy but not in a bad way. Classic good long island slice.

Great football patsy

Best Sicilian slice around

Great Sicilian pie, lots of basil is a plus for me

Good pizza fresh but too hot they may have got a bad wrap on how hot the slice was

Sex

Strong slices with a good flavorful bite. The cheese is more forward in proportion so this comes down to your preference. If you prefer extra cheeses, this will score much higher for you.

The best around hands down, regular slice is perfect in my opinion, but the Sicilian is the best Sicilian slice you'll ever have!

The flavor on this slice stood out. It was really tasty and filled with fresh ingredients. A little too much cheese for my liking, which gave it flop and hurt the crispness (cheese lovers will score it higher). However, the crust and the undercarriage were spot on. Great local spot.