Crico's Pizza & Subs

We had the All Meat, PB&J, and the Supreme. All 3 were really good. We also had wings, also good! Super nice people!

Cheesy, great pepperoni, great crust at an amazing price!!! Worth the trip!

One of the most forgettable pizzas I’ve ever had… The crust had limited flavor and massive flop, and the same can be said about the cheese. The sauce had a little bit of tang, but there was nothing special about it - I also wasn’t a fan of the after taste. None of the ingredients were fresh, but I guess that’s par for the course for being “on an island”. At the end of the day, the pizza was fine - but it was far from being great while also being far from being bad. The quest to find good pizza south of the Mason-Dixon continues…

6.8 that's a review

Solid pizza- good undercarriage and toppings, but a bit chewy for my taste.

Not bad but not great! Little too cheesy and not quite done to my liking!

perfect for dinner on the beach. undercarriage is perfect, no flop. sauce needs some more flavor.

Delicious pineapple Hawaiian guy. Highly recommend

Sauce needs more flavor. Solid in a pinch pizza! Not too bad, not too great!

Hand tossed. Fresh ingredients. Always a solid slice.

Very floppy, dough not crispy, best part was the pepperoni. Cheese seems cheap, no grease but tons of cheese on top.

I read someone said it was like a better Pizza Hut and I would have to agree. Not bad but I’d say it’s one of the better ones in the area.

First impression was it looked very good. I ordered the meat lovers and it definitely held up to its name. A lot of meat but it just seemed to lack full flavor. The sauce was light with a light tomato flavor. I prefer more sauce so that is just my opinion. The money shot is the BREADSTICKS! Definitely gotta have an order. Will probably return just for the breadsticks only. Service was great though.

Similar but a little better than Pizza Hut. Super similar to the type of pizza but not as greasy.

veryyyyyy good

Tastes fresh, I liked the crust

Good cheese taste and flavorful sauce. The crust leaves much to be desired.

Really doughy and cheesy, good tasting cheese and crust, lots of flop thought... does not pass Flop test. Minimal sauce but tasty