Delmar Pizzeria

Give it a score dave

PHENOMENAL SLICE. This place deserves a line out the door. Perfect cheese to sauce ratio, amazing tasting marinara, no complaints! Must try place! I’ve tried Dave’s highest rating 9.4 Di Fara pizza literally 20 min ago and ran back to this place. 100% recommend!

It’s a hometown favorite, this was my first time back in 20 years and it brought me back to nostalgia town. If Dave was to ask me what my favirite pizzeria was I’d say Delmars.

Born and raised in nyc. Have had almost every solid pizza spot. Delmars has got to be the best slice I’ve ever had.

The regular slice is a basic good slice. Nothing wrong with it, not too sweet, decent crisp. but also nothing amazing about it. Classic NY slice, I'm for it. The vodka slice I got is a 6.3 you barely taste the vodka on this one

Everyone knows delmar vodka pie is the bees knees

My childhood slice

Not what it used to be

Decent slice. Very greasy. Nice crisp on the slice. Ordered 2 pies around lunch time and it was a delivery. Maybe what they sell in the store is better. Very salty slice. Sauce and cheese are ok but don't stand out. Make sure to have plenty of water after having this slice.

Square slice I give a 7.8 Regular slice I give a 7.1 So overall this is a 7.5 not bad pizza at all, just super greasy but still very good.

Been a big fan of their Sicilian w/pepperoni Very Well done. Good balance, slight tang, light and airy, tasty, doesn't need additional seasoning Round is your Go To

It’s good pizza Frankie

Neighborhood Classic

Since I now live in New Jersey, anytime I am in Sheepshead Bay, I have to make my way to Delmar for one of the best slices in NYC. The slice has zero flop and is extra crispy. It had a little more grease than I remembered but it didn’t matter because the slice is that good. I was surprised over the $3 price for the slice but I guess that’s because the area has high rents. I would have eaten a few more slices but I am going across the street to Wheelers and I am looking forward to eating some Steak Tidbits.

Good slice, heavy on the cheese which means more grease but good sauce.

Square wasn’t great. Slice was on point.. 100% go with that.

Crisp, yet greasy. Nice oregano flavor.

Thin crispy crust but a little over cooked

Really good average NY slice. No flop. A bit to crispy and a little too much grease. Less greasy and not as well done would put this in the 8s.

Typical football pizza. A little greasy but overall a decent slice.