DeLucia's Brick Oven Pizza

Good cheese, good sauce, but crust was lacking.

Definitely in my top 5, score reflects that. Great quality all around which should be obvious for a 100 year business. Crispy, great quality cheese, sauce and pepperoni. Slightly thicker on the edge than I was expecting but it was fantastic

Worth all the hype!

Needs Salt desperately. Just a little tweak and it could be great.

Took a trip from Chicago to get some East Coast pizza. WOW! Delucia's is my second highest score. Pizza was crispy, sauce was perfect, and the mozzarella was to die for. Top notch even for the 1.5 hour wait. It's worth every mile traveled.

The best pizza I’ve had in the USA. Came all the way from Dallas, TX to try this amazing pizza.

Best pizza I have ever eaten. Pizza perfection.

Driving from Florida on my way to see family in New England stopped by to try. Ingredients super fresh and was very tasty. If you love crispy pizza like Dave does then this is your Graceland.

9.1 without a doubt. One of NJ’s finest. Giving a 9.2 will be unfair bc I gave federici’s a 9.1 and I like federici’s as equal to this. I’m still looking for my 9.1 and above pizza, maybe a New Haven run?

Some great pie

Pizza was good but a little doughy and not flavorful. I had to eat it fast because as it cooled down it just became dry. I guess I expected more because of the high score from Dave. Overall, compared to other pies it’s good, but not outstanding…

Awesome pie, definitely lives up to the hype. Cheese and sauce are delicious and crust has no flop.

Definately a no flop pizza. We drove 3.5 hours to try the pizza.

Very fresh, crispy, good taste. Friendly staff. Pay attention to the store hours before going. My wait wasn't that long.

It's Delucia's......... my family has been going there for 4 generations. My great great grandmother used to go there to buy bread when it was a bakery. I've been eating pizza there since I was three years old. At first I was a little pissed at Mr. Portnoy for giving it the top score because all these barstool sports people are coming in and invading this pizza place which nobody knew about but at the end of the day, I'm happy for Christian and happy for DeLucia getting the recognition that it's so much deserves. Dave try the calzone next time.

So good, a little to crunchy for my liking but omg

Very over rated, thought it was going to be the holy grail. Still a solid slice. Would prefer almost every place in New Haven.

I'm my opinion it wasn't worth the hype. Maybe because we got the first pizza of the day. Little to much cheese and needed to be firmed up.

Cooked to perfection . Probably the best I have ever had !