Dewey's Pizza - Oakley Square

Crust: Deweys tends to light bake their crust, making it fluffier with less crisp. However, the pizza held pretty well and did not flop. Sauce: The sauce was well seasoned. It even has a light sweetness to it but in the background. Very good. Cheese: Great quality and flavorful cheese. The cheese had almost no grease on it which is a huge plus for me. Value: The pizza is a little bit pricey, however for it being around $20 for a 17 inch, I believe that you get your money’s worth, especially considering the quality. Overall: Highly recommend.

I hate to score this pizza low because the dough tastes great. The only problem is that the crust is doughy. The taste is on-point but the texture has to be there. This is more pizza bread than pizza. Great toppings and the kids can watch the crew sling dough through the window which is awesome! Disclaimer: I had the pizza fresh but didn’t take a pic in the restaurant. I also added ranch because it’s leftover pizza 🤷🏻‍♂️

Above average but nothing special. Sauce has a slight spicy kick to it. Good undercarriage but no crisp. They tend to undercook them but this one was more well done than usual which I like.

Decent. A little floppy. Crust is doughy, some flavor but nothing to write home about it.

Sauce, gross. Cheese, weird. Not good... sorry Columbus>Cincy in the pizza scene

OK here we go first review - Got scared seeing signs around town bragging about voted best salad "Who Cares" don't go to a pizza place if you're on a diet! Decent first bite - Crust 2.0 good crunch and chew - Sauce 1.8 a little watery but great flavor - Cheese 1.8 a little heavy on it but it worked and not to salty like some cheapo's that use junk - Location 2.1 great phone order, clear conversation, clean place I wouldn't mind eating in and open windowed kitchen to see decent looking crew taking care of business! Great job guys!

Good cheese and crust. The sauce is a little too flavorful for me.

Good crust

Average pizza at an above average price. Priced similarly to some of the best pizza spots in town, which is nuts. The sauce is good and keeps this score above the Frankie Line. 5.2

Thin crust style pizza with a nice crispy crust. Meatball pizza was my first choice when trying this place out and highly recommend.

Ridiculously good pizza. Amazing crust. Some of the best pizza money can buy. #OneBite