East Coast Pizzeria

Top Notch New style! Pizza Scores: Pizza scores: Value-8.6 (good bang for your buck) Bake-8.8 cooked wonderfully for this size and crust style. No flip and great crisp Toppings-9.2 excellent quality of toppings. Cheese had superb taste Crust-9.4 maybe the best part. Excellent brick burn taste. Excellent crisp Sauce- 8.3 No frills taste but excellent choice on amount. Not too much, not dry. So far my favorite New York style in Columbus Ohio

Pretty good all around.

Good solid pizza, a bit above average around Columbus as far as this style goes

Very solid pie. Wish it would’ve been left in the oven for like 1 more minute but still can’t complain. Great cheese slice

Great pizza!! Crust had a perfect crisp to it. It did have a little grease but I loved it!

Great crust. Very crispy but still has a little flop to it. Pepperoni is awesome.

This is one time I wish I didn’t order pepperoni, all it added was grease not flavor. The crust was solid on this pie with good crunch.

Greasy and sloppy cheese, but it’s tasty. Crust has a nice crunch.

Best NY style pizza in Columbus.

It’s good, but definitely not the best

THE BEST PIZZA IN COLUMBUS. ‘Nuff said.

Solid New York style pizza, not the best I’ve had, but definitely better than most Columbus style pizzas. The crust was a little too over cooked for my liking.

Nice slice! Cooked perfect. Definitely NY style and that’s always a good thing.

This place stands alone in the 614 when it comes to a NY style pie. The cheese and sauce are high quality, the under carriage has a nice crisp to it, and the crisp is almost perfect.

Perfectly cooked brick fired pizza that gives the pizza a nice crunch. The pizza is a bit wet and greasy. Sauce has minimal flavor which holds this pizza back from being in the 8’s

Lots of flop. Greasy. Good flavor. Sauce is average. Thin crust but not crisp.

Crust is perfect, pizza is always delicious. This place is amazing.

Good pizza ,slices are huge Crust is ok maybe a little under done

Good slice. Hey reviews - must be cheese!! The original. Great people run this place. Very good pizza. Prez would tell you a 7.5 is very good so 8 has to be amazing. But very good food at this place

I’m from NYC. This is the most authentic New York pizza i have found in CBUS to date. Perfect flop. Crunchy but pliable crust. Sauce is seasoned really well, not too sweet. Perfect sauce to cheese ratio. Slightly greasy. But the taste is SPOT ON!