Eddie And Sam's N.Y Pizza

Not bad. Some what dry. Don’t know how long it was sitting on the rack.

Not a bad slice. Perfect crunch that goes so good with the DC. Ranch was the star of the show if you couldn’t tell… got a little excited

Awesome pizza

Stop #3 on our pizza crawl. Much much better than it looks. It appeared like it would be doughy and floppy but crispy with a great undercarriage I wasn’t looking forward to this place due to Portnoy’s review as we have similar pizza tastes. It turned out to be my favorite of the day. 8.4.

Pretty good overall, especially for the price! On point with Dave's score. 7.1

Ok plain slice, not the greatest. Their Sicilian is the way to go, probably a 7.9 for that.

Very greasy pie, you know the type of pie that tastes solid in the moment, but sits in ur stomach for a little too long. Lots of flop, sauce is solid but a little too much cheese. Not great but not bad at all

Good drunk pizza. Sober - all cheese and grease. Virtually no sauce. You need to load on the garlic powder, pepper and red pepper flakes.

Great pizza for Tampa, a very good slice, scores about a 7.8 compared to nyc pizza.

Presidente was wrong. This is some of the best pizza you can get in Tampa. Sturdy undercarrige, bubbles, crisp but flavorful dough. Great topping options, fresh and ready faster than fast food. Hard to beat!

Buffalo chicken slice is super solid - for big slices there isn’t too much grease or flop. And the crust does taste like NY.

Has ever peed their pants?

Chicken Parm was very good, sweeter sauce then expected, but very good

Solid crunch. No flop. Lacking overall flavor and love in the sauce. Has potential but just doesn’t slap.

Properly rated. Solid New Yorker