660 Yelp Reviews
sean.newsome18/7/22, 3:46 a.m.
The Emmy burger is the reason to go here, but this is a pizza review app. The pizza here is actually very good. I would put it on par with Lucali’s. Worth the trip.
adammjensen7/8/22, 7:05 a.m.
Disclaimer: I asked for the “red planet” which is double sauce and no cheese, with cheese. I wanted to guarantee myself enough sauce and I got it alright. Sauce is bomb, made the pie. I didn’t go with their “original”, but fuck it close enough
standarsh69er9/19/21, 5:04 p.m.
Sunday pizza makes me think of nights in the Caribbean with Susan. She was such a nice gal. I miss her
bedstuypizzacritic4/8/21, 10:47 p.m.
It was good, the dough isn't very pizzaey reminded me more of pastry
jtm272711/22/20, 11:40 p.m.
The best "new school", non-New York style pizza I've had in the city. Ordered the pepperoni, the charred crust was by far my favorite part. In my opinion, this pizza actually is what people hype Roberta's up to be. I have completely different thoughts on the (in my opinion) overpriced/overrated burger, but the pizza is truly excellent.
ecao10/11/20, 7:52 p.m.
Colony pizza: pepperoni is good, flavors all went together pretty well; however, a bit of a honey infestation, a bit too sweet; very oily; relatively wet; crust and crunch were good, but again, a bit wet; didn’t really taste the cheese and sauce; a good pizza with a good mix of flavors, but pales in comparison to their burger
tom.brennan3/10/20, 11:16 a.m.
Emily pie is one of the greatest pizzas I have ever eaten . All the pizzas are fancy pizzas but very good sauce is great would eat this every day. Emily pizza (the white pie) is truly amazing
cliff.jones2/16/20, 4:18 a.m.
This is good. The sauce is sweet. It’s crispy. Slightly charred. Amazing. Highly recommend.
jtrap11/11/19, 11:34 p.m.
Good wood fired pizza. Top pie was a white pie with blue cheese. That was the better of the two. Bottom is the Luca. Not a fan of the cold mozzarella on top but the sauce was good.
ryan.mcloughlin11/4/19, 2:25 a.m.
We got the Emily. Mozzarella, pistachio, truffle sottocenere, and honey. The dough is naan-like — very thin and buttery. Pizza was very rich and perfect to share for two. Overall, very unique. I’m really glad I tried it. I would recommend going out of your way to try it. I previously tried the colony pizza. I liked the colony pizza more.
thepizzajunkie11/7/18, 10:15 p.m.
Pizza Emily is trendy wood oven pizza with a good reputation in my neighborhood...miraculously got a table and pizza was outstanding but not even as good as the burger which was top 3 restaurant burger I’ve had...get the burger if you can (they only make 25 a night) and the Colony (red sauce, pepperoni, jalapeños and honey drizzle)...Margherita is good but not in league with Lucali
andrew.parke8/28/18, 1:19 a.m.
One of the top pies I’ve had in NYC. Asian influences, Crispy charred crust, and very high quality ingredients make for a unique pizza experience.