Enzo's New York Square

Score for standard only Eye test- ok Ratio - too cheesy Execution- above average Cheese - perfect. A hint of funk and very fresh. Excellent quality Sauce - a hint of sweet. Solid, fresh Dough - great bake & nice crunch, taste very neutral. Average It does all come together Neighborhood worthy for sure Not travel worthy Community score too generous but it is pretty solid pizza Bonus grandma - overheated the slice but the quality was obvious despite the lack of precision in the reheat: 7.6 Quote of the day: nope

Great pie! If you are in the Elkton area, I highly recommend Enzo's!

Very good slice great crunch and solid bite

So good!! Every bite had a crunch. Sauce was sweet. Loved it

Not bad. Good everything. Just basic quality pizza

Grandmas margarita pizza I did get half sausage. Sauce is delicious great undercarriage crispy crust. It’s definitely a great pizza.

Grandma slice is the go to here but the Sicilian was also great. This is a contender for best in the area.

Review 448 the plain slice was good not much crisp a bit sloppy but just came out of the brick oven. 7.3. Good sauce. The Grandmom is the winner the chunky sauce delicious nice crisp to it and large slice. 2 slices and soda $10bukcks Grandmom was a 8.5

Really amazing Sicilian style. Excellent sauce, snappy cheese and pillowy soft crust with a caramelized bottom.

Multiple bites and everybody knows the rules. Great crust, great sauce and a great place enjoy pizza watching the pizza chef making pizza live.

Grandma pie Wow just amazing the sauce is sweet and fresh. The crust has so much flavor light and crisp great cheese . My only problem is it doesn't come in a bigger size. I wish I lived near this place had it delivered to the truck stop.

Solid pie. Nothing fancy. Good crust. Anyone rating higher than this is just an amateur.

A great pizza deserving of a great score. And in Elkton, MD of all places! The sauce and cheese were FANTASTIC. Fresh, light, flavorful and perfectly executed. Rivaled some of the very best I’ve had anywhere. Crust was solid but a tad chewy. Enzo Baby, if you get me that crust crispier, you’re looking at a high-high 8 score. Overall a must stop! 🤌

Looks and smells amazing. Crust has a nice crisp, but tasted a bit bland or maybe a bit old. Sauce had nice flavor. I had high hopes for this place, best in the area doesn't mean much around here.

Ok, so the pizza isnt in the picture, but i really wanted you to see the sandwiches this place makes. They’re huge! Theyre almost the size of a slightly flattened volleyball. They have a butter garlic sauce and some grated parm or pecorino on top. Probably Locatelli. This place is awesome! I cant believe im still in Maryland. This pizza holds its own anywhere. I tried all 3 styles today. The Thin Round with ground sausage, the Plain Sicilian square, and the Grandma. Hard to pick a favorite. They were all amazing. The plain round with sausage looked so good i had to pass up on the plain cheese. It was so crispy and light with a nice little cheese pull and a really nice sauce 8.2. The Grandma was so fresh and tasty. The dough was thin and light with one heck of a crunch around the edge. Zero flop. Fresh Mozzarella is laid down first on this pie and then scattered dollops if a chunky sauce that almost blew my dick off. Fresh torn basil leaves on top always gets you points from me. 8.4 on the Grandma. The Sicilian was thick, with a crispy buttery bottom and a pillowy cloud inside. The sauce and cheese was good, but not as good as that Grandma. Id like to try a sicilian, topped like a Grandma. Sicilian is an 8.4 because the bread was bangin. The service was top notch. The man who owns this joint is super fuckin Italian. Guy probably has marinara in his arteries. Cant wait to try this pizza again.

Awesome sicilian pizza! Great crust good sauce! Best in area for sure

OMG this is a good slice. Crust sauce cheese all balanced all works well.

This pizza is in the conversation for the best I've had. I'm not too cultured, but I do eat a lot of pizza

This is Great pizza! I can't believe that I have slept on this place for so long. I've been working in Maryland on and of for years and I've been this area for about 2 months. This is by far the best pizza that I have had in this state. The Grandma slice was one of the best I've ever had, easy 9+. So fresh and crispy, not greasy at all. The plain slice was thin and super crispy with a great sauce and cheese blend 8.3. I love it here. Really tastes and feels like a NY/NJ slice. Perfecto! Next time I'm getting the Sicilian.

Very good pizza but I have a sneaking suspicion that the real winner in this place is the speciality slices. But we eat cheese and cheese only. Sauce has great flavor and there is the perfect amount of cheese. Crust is a little too crunchy for me to go much higher. You won’t be disappointed if you stop in.

Solid pie in Elkton, MD. The pizza was great and the people were even better. Little heavy on the flop but solid, fresh ingredients set this pie apart.