Ernie's Pizzeria

Quality za, no flop even though it was a heavy pie. Very crisp with every bite. The sauce was fantastic but it wasn’t very distributed on the pie. It was all concentrated up towards the crust. the crust was good but didn’t have much flavor to it. The cheese was delicious but there was a little to much of it. I was debating a 7.9 or a 8.1 but I feel like this place has potential to be in the upper 8s if it can make some minor adjustments.

Really good. Very cheesy. Good crust.

Ernie’s Special. The best part was the crust, great pizza overall.

Ernie’s special was crispy, with limited flop. Garlicky and delicious but I want more sauce on my pie. Good pizza that falls in New Haven’s second tier.

Amazing. Super cheesy. Love it so much...

Excellent pizza! Thanks Big Ernie.

Bangin pie, uneven cook

Solid pie. Little tang, good under-carriage. Great new haven pie

Would have been better if it were cooked a bit longer. Good pizza but doesn’t compare to the New Haven big boys. Don’t travel from far to come here.

Clarification: last post was for a THIN-CRUST pizza Let’s get one thing straight: this was still a good thick crust pizza. However, nowhere near as good as it could have been. Pizza was undercooked. Please zoom into the middle of the pizza and see a soupy/liquid pond. Crust had a nice crisp. I was let down to say the least...

I grew up on this pizza and literally a mile away! It's a cheese focused pizza and a bit too greasy overall, but the cheese has a good flavor and the crust is good and super crispy. I wish it had more sauce and more flavor in the dough, but it's always consistently good. That crisp though!

Sausage and mushroon on left, bacon and onion on right, also you have to try the plain mozz. All of them were amazing!

Solid slice

I SAY 8..