Would have been better if it were cooked a bit longer. Good pizza but doesn’t compare to the New Haven big boys. Don’t travel from far to come here.
dongled8/17/19, 10:34 p.m.
Very greasy, but well cooked and amazing taste. Sweet sauce. Great slice.
ap06177/17/19, 8:39 p.m.
Great crunch. Great crust. Lots of cheese. Not enough sauce to give it that great flavor.
joann.vitali7/12/19, 1:03 a.m.
Always went to the other big 3 in New Haven until Dave reviewed this. This is now my go to whenever I go home to visit!
scrants7/2/19, 11:49 p.m.
Lrg mozz 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 sausage. Crust was very crispy, but a little bland compared to the top Elm city spots. Sauce and cheese were spot on. Very good pie.
xxmorpheus6/25/19, 11:52 p.m.
One bite, everyone knows the rules. Nice size pie. Somewhat greasy, not horrible though. Slight flop, good initial crunch. Cheese fresh. Good even cheese taste. Sauce slightly bland, not bad, very traditional. Tasty crunch on the crust. Very solid pizza, very solid score.
bryan.c25/25/19, 1:05 p.m.
Extremely cheesy and a bit greasy as well. Nonetheless, very fresh taste and cooked to perfection. Also, love the crust. Overall, a solid pie that I will definitely have again.
hindah2/28/19, 11:48 p.m.
Hot Fresh Crust great! Very good pie.... Bit greasy and too light on sauce is only down fall
jabroner2/25/19, 11:18 p.m.
Small neighborhood joint with some die hard regulars. New Haven flop but only because the cheese was flowing so hard. A little too much for my liking, if they cut it back 25% then this is in the mid 8s all day. But to each his own on pizza style, definitely sets them apart from other NH joints. The Dough was really well perfected - good char, crust had some major league bubbles that were delicious. This ranking is for the Plain Cheese pie but that Spinach/Bacon/Garlic/Mozz/Red Sauce was freaking bomb! Note: My original photo never saved so I took a photo of the photo. Got the job done for One Bite sake.
andrew.kush1/20/19, 12:13 a.m.
Lotta grease Frankie and a good amount of flop... but nice char on bottom and crust...good mozzarella and sauce. I got it with fresh garlic because the guy next to me was raving about it... I honestly thought it over-powered the pizza, but it was good. I ate 4 slices so very satisfied... closest thing to Sally’s/ Pepe’s experience while on the west end of town.
kennyho12/22/18, 8:17 p.m.
Far too much grease for me. Crust makes this a decent pie. After 5 slices I had to go down to a 6.5
collinbrady12/22/18, 8:10 p.m.
Grease bomb, no flop, solid flavor, a little different than normal new haven style. Not mad that I came in.
sam.regler12/5/18, 11:25 p.m.
Food slice. Surprised they were able to get the dough to rise being that they were using CT water. Super cheesy, not very saucy, which isn’t necessarily bad.
nicole.9/6/18, 3:21 a.m.
Favorite pizza growing up & still is to this day- even after moving to NYC. perfect cheese, perfect sauce flavor, great crust.
jdalto48/28/18, 7:27 p.m.
You haven’t had Pizza until you’ve had the fresh tomato pie from Ernie’s.